Showing posts with label Books. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Books. Show all posts

Saturday, 6 October 2007

"Is nothing sacred?!"

This cry went up in a class this week.

We were using Alice in Wonderland as a springboard text to discuss other things, but there was some serious objection to 'studying' (that is, rigorous questioning, finding out, and thinking about) a book that people had read as young (ish) children. The idea behind the objection, I think, was a horror that the original childhood impressions of the magical tale might be overwritten with the intrusion of adult eyes; the child's brain had been put in a sparkly pink box (or perhaps a more fitting slightly sinister one, given the weirdness of Alice) and was Not To Be Touched.

The Annotated Alice text exacerbated this problem - it's a fantastic and eclectic peering at Carroll's stories through every conceivable kind of eyes - the historical, the mathematical and physical, the cultural, the literary, the adult...But this was, it seemed, just too much information; too intrusive, too questioning, too learned and - God forbid! - perhaps even reading too much into the stories. Hang on a minute, isn't that the line Literature students (of all levels of experience and competence) walk along all the time? But because this text was in some way held sacred, because of childhood experience, the tolerence level dropped completely - 'You are not touching this text, this memory', Tolerence hissed, 'It's mine. My precious...' (Gollum was there too).

I have to admit I was irritated, because - when it comes to the study of Literature (and other things) - I do not think that anything should be protected from questioning. Nothing is sacred when it comes to academia (however microscopically tiny that academia might be). I'm here to ask questions, and to keep on answering them until something relents, or I realise it's a stupid question, or I die. I am not here to pussy-foot around people's fluffy constructions of what they think a book was about once. That is not at all interesting.

There is something intensely annoying about Arts students (in this sense, Literature, Music and Art) who will only go as far as - or are content to stop at - a feeling about something. I'm not denying that certain arts can make humans react in an emotional (or irrational, though I'm not using those two things synonymously) way, but I am saying that that is absolutely not what studying the arts is about. Or, if it is, I'm definitely doing the wrong thing. The absence of a desire to scrutinise is incomprehensible, to me, in people who are otherwise enviably bright. If they want to hold onto a cute idea of what certain texts are, it's perhaps questionable whether they're studying the right subject. Or maybe I'm studying the wrong one. Why not give Lolita or Bleak House to a kid, ask them what it's about, and leave it at that? Because that doesn't work. Et voila, nor does that attitude to Alice. Grow up - or at least be open to the possibility that there might be a giant rabbithole even in adult life.

Wednesday, 12 September 2007

Introductions

What is the purpose of an Introduction to a work of fiction?

I'm sure every editor has asked exactly that question before writing an intro (or before commissioning someone else to do so), but there certainly doesn't seem to have been an agreement anywhere. So it seems reasonable enough to ask it again. An introducing of something presumes -- doesn't it? -- that the thing being introduced, and the thing being introduced to have not met previously. Otherwise they'd be called "Reintroductions", or "Reminders". Reading decent editions of texts, though, often means being faced with (or outfaced by) a 'scholarly' introduction complete with obscure references to little things within the text, and a bamboozling array of facts (be they critical, historical, political, chronological or anything elseical). These very clever, very carefully researched critical essays are a great resource, but I don't think they serve well as introductions. They often don't make any sense whatsoever to readers coming to the text for the first time; which is surely self-defeating on the part of the introduction?

It very much depends on who is writing it. In the vast number of publications of the two editions I most frequently use (Oxford World's Classics, and Penguin) there is great variation in the apparent intentions, and end results, of the introductions. Some seem barely more than plot summaries (this is sometimes useful, because I am Not Good at remembering names of characters so it's a quick reminder; on the other hand, it doesn't tell you more than the text proper could); some are academic hard-ons (probably great fun for the writer, but a little uncomfortable for the audience); some get the balance better and provide information giving insight, but not so much that the all-important text itself is obscured behind academia so dense it causes all but the most trained eye to glaze over.

It must be a difficult balance to strike.
As I see it, an introduction should be like good gossip: more information than the original source can (or wants to) give you, but not so much sordid detail that you feel as if you're bitching unnecessarily.

Friday, 7 September 2007

Limax

Scattered things, from a bear of very little brain:

1) Limax means "slug". Somehow I find it very satisfying that such a strange little animal should have a Latin name (why I'm surprised, I don't know - but I've never wondered what that name was before). Next time I stand on one with bare feet (that is, me with bare feet, not the slug. It only has one foot), I shall exclaim: "Ghastly limax!" instead of the usual "Fucking slimeball". The study of slugs is "limacology". If I have a (dramatic) change of heart re: career, I might endeavour to become a limacologist. As it is, I'm heading more towards being "limaciform" [slug-like]. Fantastic word.

2) Fugues, fugues, fugues. I'm meant to be doing an English degree, right? Apparently this involves me teaching myself all that music theory again so I can attempt to form a coherent argument about a book. It is, of course, a good challenge and I'm enjoying it a lot. But I really wish I'd carried on with it earlier (ah, the joy of retrospect) - I only studied it up to the required level in order to continue with my practical instrumental exams...and that was when I was 12...Anyway, I've always hated playing fugues on the piano - have never been able to get my head (and fingers) round them when they're more than 3 parts. But playing with the theory is quite a different matter, and allows me to read brilliant books that aren't just about the music side of things (a Good Thing, because I am NOT doing a music degree!) . Particularly Hofstadter's Godel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid, which makes much more sense now than it did 7 years ago. (A relief). Leading to...

3) ...fugues, seuguf, fugues...An inevitable result of my reading about and taking apart fugues again is a renewed attempt to play them. It's not proving much more successful than before, but I'm enjoying it more (certainly the result of the non-presence of Evil Piano Teacher).

4) Volunteering to make the committee T-shirts for College seemed like a good idea months ago. Two weeks before going back it is no longer such a great idea. Whoops! I like my design, but getting it onto the shirts [a] in time and [b] without making a huge mess is going to be a hassle.

5) A warning from the Hofstadter book above, which rings worryingly in relation to my Interminable Essay (of which, without doubt, more later - it's not submitted till April, so plenty of time for dithering and moaning about it): "It is of course important to try to maintain consistency, but when this effort forces you into a stupendously ugly theory, you know something is wrong." Quite. I shall keep an eye out for stupendous ugliness. Good way of putting it.

Friday, 31 August 2007

Gaps

Well, it appears what happens when Crumpetty gets really busy is...gaps. Big ones. Expect more. Never mind. Some things:

1) Attempting to read Rubin's The Hollow Crown was once more not successful (tried last year, too), and I'll probably give up. It's is not the best book about the Middle Ages, and made me a bit cross. Facts have a habit of being incredibly boring and unmemorable unless extremely carefully (and skilfully) presented, and that's unfortunately what happens in this book. I'm not one to shirk a challenge (unless it involves roller-coasters or shellfish), but I've decided there are better books about similar things. Such as...

2) ...Alison Weir's biography of Isabella, which is excellent. Weir has written a lot - on the bookshelves her output volume visually compares to that of Antonia Fraser (and they both write on very similar things, which might make for interesting comparison some time). Weir constructs biography and pieces together history very cleverly, and although her texts are laden with facts (with even brief endnotes coming close to 100 pages) the writing never feels heavy, confusing or dull. She weaves a good story; and although liberties are taken to bend [lack of] evidence to her will, it's not too annoying. I've just got hold of Eleanor of Aquitaine, too, and look forward to reading it. She's very recently branched out into historical fiction for the first time, with Innocent Traitor, centred around Lady Jane Grey - there's a possibility this might soon(ish) become a TV drama, so watch this space!

3) A week in very soggy Cambridge, hidden in cosy libraries and quiet spots. With endless thanks to LJJ for being a wonderful work companion, even (especially?) when we haven't a clue what each other is talking about! Some work needed a bit of a kick-start and that seemed a good place to do it. Lots of fun, and I managed to have An Idea - which so far has been resilient to crushing. It's probably only a matter of time until the Inevitable Problem occurs, but there is hope! A little grouse, though: people who write in library books. Little marks/comments/pictures in margins are fine, but one reader (and it was one) scribbled his (and it was most definitely a 'his') way through two entire volumes of a biography I was trying to read - this amounted to about 900 pages of MESS. Some paragraphs were unreadable because of his enthusiasm. Enough already.

4) I've come across an author who manages, quite uncannily, to write frighteningly relevant texts. The sentences seem to encapsulate everything that matters, and everything that doesn't. Not going to say who it is, or which books, because that would reveal more about my way of thinking about the world and myself than I will ever admit. I am curious to know if I feel the same way about the books in twenty years...Is this simply indicative of where I'm at now? Or what I fundamentally am? Presumably if the effect is indelible I'll remember to revisit the words to find out.

Tuesday, 14 August 2007

Justifiable

Work-avoidance is at its best served warm and justifiable - and as one of those lucky people who is interested in almost anything, justification is generally close to hand. Two things keeping me from being Little Miss Efficient today (whilst simultaneously teaching me some genuinely useful things):

1) Practicing reading Early-Modern scripts and manuscripts online. This is one of the most thoughtfully and effectively presented websites I've seen - it's fantastic! The idea is that one might learn and practice reading ye olde handwritings and scribal scratchings by following an impeccably designed and managed set of 'lessons', in which texts of differing complexities are transcribed. The site is maintained by Andrew Zurcher, who knows his and everyone else's stuff - an invaluable site for all Spenser nuts is also maintained by him (without which my Renaissance reading would [have] be[en] all the more anaemic). The handwriting site is an example of how the 'net can and should be put to best effect. That and YouTube, obviously.

2) First there was Pepys, now there's Roger Morrice. Well, not so much "now" as "there was also" - he's well dead. But a compatriot diary to Pepys' is very welcome; he's cited so much that it's good to have another text to go to, similar in form but different in content. This is fairly exciting, given I can already spend hours buried in a volume of Ypesp. It's always 'relevant', because I'm always reading something from the period (or thereabouts) - perfect procrastination, and with bonus educational benefits. A bit more information: here. When Newnham Library acquires the Morrice, that much less Real Work will get done - probably ought to pre-empt that by working now. Probably...

Saturday, 11 August 2007

Miscalculation

It took me two days rather than one to get to the end of Richard III's reign - but what's one more day when this project has run a week over already? Actually, I'm not quite going to stop yet - though I've finished the 'learning' part of things for now - next stop is Miri Rubin's The Hollow Crown: A History of Britain in the late Middle Ages. Nothing like a bit of immediate consolidation...or it might be procrastination, but I'm not really sure what from, given that my dissertation's going to have its very own University Library Time next week! All this reading is highly relevant to the Medieval Lit Paper we'll be doing next term, but it feels like I'm indulging my fascination with hi-stories (or, in later periods, His-Tories) rather than Proper Books. Still, more than enough time for that, always.

What's got me gripped about this whole thing is the variation in reports of the period (say, mid-13th century till end of the 15th). There are inevitably big gaps in evidence, and so much of what we 'know' is formed by propaganda of the various factions - like the stories about Isabella (Edward II's queen), or Margaret of Anjou (Henry VI's queen), or Joan of Arc. It's not all about the women - Richard III is a weird and wonderful case in point there, and Henry V - but the woman are particularly interesting because they don't often speak for themselves. There are some letters - about which I know very little, and I've no idea how much they say - but the overwhelming majority of the Middle Ages is written by men. The same can be said for later periods, but far less so - from the 16th century aristocratic women start writing and existing (and sponsoring) much more, and though there are serious limitations those women have at least gained a kind of retrospective freedom: we can hear them. Some might have been respected by their contemporaries (Magdalene Herbert, for example - the poet George Herbert's mother, famous in her own right), but many were ignored or ridiculed or excluded (Margaret Cavendish might take some or all of those titles). The difference being that, however they were perceived at the time, their written words have given them a posterity and a chance at being re-evaluated by subsequent generations. The persons of Medieval women are much quieter, and much more dependent on their contemporary menfolk for their reputations. Never a good idea.

A pretty good book for a starting point is Mark Ormrod's The Kings and Queens of England. Each of the royal Houses constitutes a chapter, and each chapter is taken by a different academic. There is some pronoun confusion (is she the sister of him, or of him? Or the daughter of him?), which often happens when a writer knows far more about the subject than their reader. Ho hum - only a minor annoyance, and the gaps have been filled in from elsewhere. It's a densely written book, which is good for saving trees, but less good for a nice casual reading book - not a beach-read, unless you have an elephantine (or professorial) memory!

Thursday, 9 August 2007

Lineage

Internet silence the last few days (a habit likely to continue in the run-up to Term and beyond), because I've been head-down in books about Medieval history - I've got as far as the Wars of the Roses and have to concentrate very hard for long stretches of text in order not to be utterly confused. Mainly because everyone's bloody called "Henry". At least in the Old Testament most people have different names (for a while, at least) - difficult, but different. The most you can hope for in the Middle Ages is that the eldest sons die so the next king's called something different. I'm really mainly focusing on the Houses of Plantagenet, Lancaster & York, but that's more than enough to go on for the time being - as it is I have post-it notes everywhere saying things like:

HENRY IV = HENRY BOLINGBROKE, EARL OF DERBY, RICHARD II's COUSIN. Opposed by HENRY PERCY = 'HOTSPUR', EARL OF NORTHUMBERLAND's SON, not to be confused with HENRY (V), PRINCE OF WALES...

...and so it goes on. Before the Henrys there were the first gaggle of Edwards; and after the Henrys more Edwards. For the purposes of this exercise I'll probably stop after Richard III - more than that won't stay in my head for long, so I'll come back to the Tudors in a few months. It's all good fun, though - finally I'm understanding what the Hundred Years War was all about (insofar as it was 'about' anything), though if I read one more time about it stopping and then restarting again I might just call it quits at Ninety Years and be in denial about the last decade or so. Who's going to notice? (Me, sadly). The only thing that doesn't seem to be improving at all is my spelling of Welsh names - I have to check every time, because I keep confusing the Welsh phonetics with the English phonetics, it's like half-knowing a language and then not being able to progress. The whole process is taking far longer than I'd planned for, though, as I'd intended to be doing this for about three days and it's already taken just over a week. I will finish tomorrow. Problem is, when I get my head into something like this I can't usually extract it until a reasonable stopping point rears up, which can become inconvenient. Still, I'm learning a lot, which can only ever be a good thing. Even if it does mean an echoing "Henry Henry Henry Henry" taking the place of tinnitus in my brain.

If there were more time I'd revisit the wonderful Histories of The Bard, if only because another factor of confusion is his fictionalization of things like Henry V's youth, and the turning of historical John Oldcastle into fictional Falstaff. And that's just one of the plays! The Histories are fantastic, and revisit them I will - although it might not be able to happen until it has to, for revision purposes.

Loosely connected to the Henrys (real and artistic) is the subject of Joan of Arc, another figure history has managed simultaneously to immortalise and almost obliterate with fictions and superstitions and - of course - politics. There's a highly recommended staging of Bernard Shaw's Saint Joan at the National Theatre (Olivier Theatre) at the moment (until September 4th), which I'd dearly love to see but probably won't be able to. The cast has some impressive names but, more importantly, Anne-Marie Duff apparently makes a convincing Joan (despite the 'Chair Thing' she appears to do - you can see it in the clip if you follow the link above). Inevitably, and probably quite properly, parallels are drawn in related essays and reviews (including those in the official programme) between martyrdom and terrorism - I'm not sure whether that is pointless or important.

[On the subject of stages and shows, it seems the British Muesum's Chinese Terracotta Army exhibition has already sold 30,000 advance tickets - if you want to go, book now!]

I've ordered Alison Weir's well-reviewed book about Edward II's formidable wife, Isabella, and intend to read it on the train to and from Cambridge next week - I'm going up to get some serious work done (it has to happen some time, wonderful though this freelance education is), and it should be some good light(ish) reading, but just related enough to what I should be doing to assuage the guilt necessarily concomitant to prescribed reading lists - victory!

Monday, 30 July 2007

Incongruities

Travelling activities, and other present participles.

1) Listening to Mozart's Requiem (find it here) very loudly in a dingy, eerily deserted, bomb-threatened railway station miles from where I wanted to be on Friday evening. Weird experience. It was entirely coincidental, but the soundtrack of the armed policemen doing their 'thing' was the Lacrimosa - if you know it, you'll know why I wanted the gun-wielding men to move in slow motion. It would have worked quite well, as a film edit. Thanks ABP & CEH for coming to rescue me from the station, at no little inconvenience to themselves!

2) Reading Twain's Adam and Eve on the train. It would have been the right length for the journey, but the three hours stuck in aforementioned station messed up the timing. It's published in a few different forms, but I was reading this one. I do like this wee piece, particularly the first couple of sections - as quiet, irreverent but loving observation, it's something fun and real. Do take a look, it is touching and very short. Funny what can be done with three chapters of Genesis, and the comparison of the way other people treat the same subject isn't a waste of time - Twain versus Milton, anyone?

3) Reading Simon Armitage's translation/rendering of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight on the return journey. This is a brilliant rendition of an already brilliant poem. Just like Heaney and his Beowulf, Armitage strikes a wonderful balance between the feel of the original text and his own distinctive poetic voice. His use of language to allow images is as gleeful as the source, and reading this is an easy pleasure. This text is a viable alternative Christmas story, if you get fed up of A Christmas Carol, The Night Before Christmas and Handel's Messiah.

4) Listening to Karl Jenkins' Adiemus: Songs of Sanctuary whilst unpacking, washing up and generally being domestic. Jenkins is often regarded as something of a 'chocolate box' composer, and I have some sympathy with that (having sung and played some of his work, repeatedly); but this is a CD worth listening to. It's a fusion (no, don't run away from that word) of 'classical' western music forms (structures), and 'ethnic' (primarily African) harmony and vocal technique. It's very listenable to, which I suspect is why lots of classical music snobs object to it. It's peaceful (a good start, given the title!), but not soporific. Something very different is his The Armed Man: A Mass for Peace - best heard live, in a BIG enclosed building like a cathedral, this is moving and pertinent and awful and hopeful. It has chocolate box moments, but I think it's one of the most important pieces of music written in our time. If there's a big version of it going on in a cathedral (or similar) near you, don't miss the opportunity.

5) Leaving a sunflower in a vase after it should really be there. There was a sunflower on my desk last week, making me smile, and I left it there over the weekend. It has died (predictably), but a curious thing has happened to its stem: all the fibrous exterior has loosened so it's like a big brush, and there's a gooey gelatinous core that's slowly dissolving away. No idea what it is, or why it's happened (other than water over-saturation, which is obvious enough), but it's not something I've seen before!

Wednesday, 25 July 2007

Loitering

Though being away from University does suck quite a lot, one thing has made all these months entirely worth it - the space and time to re-read. Of course I'm looking forward to going back (9 weeks and 3 days, though I'm not counting...), but being able to read and re-read has been a luxury for which I'm thankful - Tripos seems to give no quarter, normally. People don't usually believe me when they find out the incalculably vast majority of my 'Literature' reading has been done in the last two years (since starting my course), but it's true - I read fiction until I was about 13, and then read mainly Philosophy, History and Politics, as well as Biology and Physics (lots of Physics) until my university interviews loomed four years later, which point seemed timely to start reading fiction again. (In case you're confused, English wasn't quite my intended career path until just before the university applications had to be finished). I'm not at all bothered by this fact, though it's very often apparent that I'm not as well read as most other Englings, because the historical/political/philosophical background always comes in handy. But it's a fact nevertheless.

With Tripos put aside for a while, then, reading could commence. All that funky sideways stuff that comes up in the course of the Papers but which never gets read because there just isn't time. Making up for lost time. I'm helped and hindered by an insatiable curiosity, with which I got tangled in Frontispiece (June). I've just been able to read anything and everything, and for once really follow up any 'Further Reading' recommendations in the backs of books. It's exciting, really. Exciting and infuriating (despite having unintended time, there still isn't enough of it to get through everything. Obviously). So I've been able to re-read the fairytales I should have been read when I was wee (I never was read them, but got round to doing it myself a few years later - but it means that Cinderella and Ugly Duckling and their ilk aren't part of my unconscious. That may well be for the better - I'm not scared of midnight, nor hopeful about ugliness); and I've been able to read more Beckett. Much more Rushdie and Eco, at last. And lots of the things so many people think are fundamental (and they are, in a way, but they weren't my building-blocks), like the Just So Stories, which I'm sure are much more interesting when read after Conrad, rather than when 6 years old - or at least that's my excuse, now. There have been some new discoveries, too: Auden and Dryden, amongst others. Reading (and the all-important re-reading) more texts by already-discovered and loved authors, in such abundance, is an unexpected treat I won't soon forget.

This might sound like I'm saying goodbye to that luxury, and I suppose in a way I am as Tripos is beginning to get its hooks back into me, and there's a dissertation that needs writing and - more pressingly - reading for. I love Tripos: without it I wouldn't have had such a want to read and read and read; but space away from it has somehow brought it, and what it stands for, closer.

Here seems as good a place as any to list some texts. These are my life-changers so far (though most good books have a very real impact, these have somehow significantly changed my thinking rather than just adding to it). If you don't like lists, look away now - I just feel like writing one! In no particular order:


  • A Room of One's Own, Woolf -- I've read this enough that now I just open it and read it whenever I'm restless or frustrated. It's calming and motivating, and really very funny. I love it for my being able to get something new from it every time. Every Newnhamite should be given a copy of it when they join the College. Maybe I'll start that tradition...
  • Paradise Lost, Milton -- It's beautiful, multi-dimensional, infinitely contentious and my 'Desert Island Book'. I can't get over how near-perfect the poetry is, and how vital almost every word. First read it in 6th Form, and it's another of those I can always open and enjoy.
  • The Good Soldier, Ford Madox Ford -- Encountered this, as a two-page extract, in a 1st yr class. I was too curious to let it lie, so read it and againandagainandagain...This wonderful writer is now the subject of my dissertation, but I really need to get past the "This dude does dead good" stage of the argument!
  • Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit, Winterson -- The themes of this mattered first, and it was only later I realised how well the thing is written. This one was read when I was about 12, and it couldn't have been better timed. It was lent to me by someone who knew me better than I did, then.
  • The Satanic Verses, Salman Rushdie -- The beginning of my interest in Literature, rather than just books. It's almost certainly this that got me doing English at Newnham, so I'm all for the man's Knighthood.
  • The Qur'an -- I read this for the first time a couple of months ago. It'll stay with me. Though I wish I could read Arabic...
  • The Henrys (IV, V & VI), Shakespeare -- Pre-University I was scared of what Shakey stood for, and avoided him. Faced with a whole term of his writing in 2006 I decided to just jump right in with the plays that frightened me most and see what happened, and I fell in love. These plays are what did it for me.
  • Fear and Trembling, Kierkegaard --The beginning of a new world, when I was 13.
  • The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock, Eliot -- I've always struggled with poetry; I love taking it apart and seeing how it works, but I don't often feel it. This is probably the first poem that grabbed something sinewy inside me and pulled until I had to give in.

Good books leave themselves in you somehow. Some deposit themselves as whispers of quotations that catch you unawares (like J. Alfred Prufrock); others as tableaus stuck in monochrome (The Handmaid's Tale, particularly, did this. I re-read it yesterday and re-visited all the old pictures, amending some too). Some of them niggle like an Ohrwurm, like this irritating song by 'Peter, Bjorn & John' (I challenge you to listen to it all the way through and then not whistle it...) - Fear and Trembling did this to me. Others draw you back to them with an invisible piece of thread they tied round you at first reading - Room of One's Own always tempts me from the bookshelf. Known books never disappoint, never betray; they change, as we do, but that's okay, that's layering rather than abandonment.

Tuesday, 24 July 2007

Implete

Call this a cop-out, if you like, but I'll defend it.

Not going to write anything of my own today, much, but am going to link to Jeanette Winterson's homepage. Go and read her Column; the whole thing, if you've lots of time, or just dib in and out and in again. I re-(re-re-)read Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit yesterday, and remembered why I've always loved Winterson's writing. Just because it is. It's new, always, and it's funny - really funny, the kind that stays with you for its truthful observation. After the recent Harry Potter doings, reading genuinely fantastic LITERATURE (all capitalized, all!) like this is like eating vegetables I've grown myself, instead of unidentifiable pre-packaged gunge. Back to real books for a while now. Though the enjoyment of reading something easy and readable and storyful after battling with Serious Things was nice, the relief of going back to that struggle is tremendous. Back at home. It's like breathing again, is reading something enduring.

There's a lot of her writing on the website - articles as well as the column. Go read. And her books. And then again.

Monday, 23 July 2007

Schemes

There are loads of organisations and initiatives around at the moment, set up to encourage everyone to simultaneously read the same book, or from a set list. It's a peculiar phenomenon, and I'm not really sure what to think. Maybe more on that another time.

At the beginning of this year the Small Island Read took place. As part of the commemorative events taking place marking the bicentenary of the abolition of the slave trade in the British Empire, it's predictable that the allocated book will have something to do with Black/White relations - and it does. The Black/White tangle is looked at in a refreshingly sideways way, though, which was a nice discovery; it would have been so easy to shove something like To Kill a Mockingbird in people's faces or, I don't know, Alice Walker (two birds, one stone - Black America and women - score). But the book chosen was Small Island by Andrea Levy.

Small Island follows four people - two black, two white - through a part of their lives. Based around the Second World War, the narrative is chronologically mixed and - because coincidence and connections are inevitable - parts of each characters' stories are told by other characters. It's simple, but quite clever. I was expecting a rehash of the ol' Black-Americans-struggling-against-White-Americans tale which, though important, has been done. Levy, though, writes about something different: she takes on the two islands of Jamaica and Britain (well, England). Only small sections of the book involve Americans, for which I'm thankful. Between the four primary characters we catch glimpses of Jamaican upbringing, England's Home Front, British involvement in India, and the effect of a steady influx of 'foreigners' into England. It's a new twist on the story it's so easy to think we know all about, and a good one. The writing is mostly fresh and original, and when it does get stodgy or predictable Levy is quick to move it on. She leaves quite a lot unwritten (particularly emotions, motives and thoughts), and whereas in some books this just makes the characters flat and unconvincing, Levy says enough to keep them alive - it's up to us to try to work them out, which suits me fine; that is, the right things are left unsaid. The ending is too neatly tied, and for that reason (I think) I found the final fifth of the book irritating - there was too much striving for a rounded end, too many resolutions and unlikely changes of heart. But so few books have fantastic endings that it hardly matters much to the whole. The book is good, surprising, sufficiently challenging and also pertinent. If you can do a Jamaican accent in your head (or aloud), all the better!

Sunday, 22 July 2007

Surprises

NO plot-spoilers in this blog.

The new Harry Potter book, The Deathly Hallows is surprising. Not so much the plot, which is what I've loved Rowling for up till now, but the writing itself. Okay, so the details of the plot are complicated and it takes some concentration to figure out what on earth's going on; but more excitingly, the way the plot is conveyed is completely different to the other books. It's densely packed, there aren't all that many superfluous clauses, and there is subtlety. It's only just over 600 pages long, but took me a good 12 hours to read (compare that to the almost-800 page 5th book, which took about 7 hours). For the first time, I think, Rowling demanded concentration and effort on the part of the reader, and it was such a better book for that - hooray! Not going so far as to say it's 'literary', it's not; but as a first toe-dip into reading tricky books, it's got something. I'm also emotionally drained having got through it. Which is probably a bit sad, but indicative - not every book can do that.

She uses a lot of ellipses, and virtually no semi-colons (I should learn from that latter). Ellipses are funny things. I use them a lot, because I'm lazy. The time for elliptical experiment has gone (cf: Ulysses and, say, Ford Madox Ford's Parades End), and it's generally it's my feeling that they shouldn't be used too much, unless they are doing something other than simply filling a space where the writer should in fact be writing words (that's how I use them, which is Bad). So Rowling uses too many ellipses, she uses them as much as Ford, but with a lesser effect. A small problem in a really good book, though. In Deathly Hallows, Rowling has demonstrated not just that she's a fantastic story-teller with an incredible imagination (that's been proved before), but that she is capable of writing concisely, delicately and densely to say her stuff. A good note to end on.

Apparently around half of Bloomsbury's revenue is Potter-related (according to the Guardian) - what on earth are they going to do in the coming years? Some investment in another type of book would be welcome - come on Bloomsbury, put some of your millions into 'unpopular' writers and make them popular.

Wednesday, 18 July 2007

Repetition

Unfortunately I anticipate that this won't be the last of Harry Potter on this blog, as he's sure to get a mention once the final book is out; but I wanted to post this, a Guardian article by Lezard, who merrily trashes J. K. Rowling's writing. I don't have a problem with what he says about her writing style and lack of subtlety (he makes the point about her discourse markers better than I did in the Preparatory blog the other day) - she isn't literarily inventive, and her books will never be anything more acclaimed than a children's literature phenomenon (aside from the unprecedented media hype, which is a subject in its own right).

What Lezard doesn't say, however, is more irksome: he doesn't mention the fantastic story-telling that is involved in her books. The almost complete world Rowling has created isn't acknowledged, and that, I think, is unfair. What we think of as 'Literature' (note capitalisation...) has its roots in simple story telling. Take the Anglo-Saxon stuff, for example - stories, it's all tales and myths and legends; passed through the oral/aural tradition for yonks before being put into the text forms we know today (Beowulf, Battle of Maldon, Dream of the Rood, amongst them). Not only are they just stories (almost always with a moral point, in one way or another), but they are stories consisting of formulaic phrases, recycled bits put together in different orders. In this light, the repetitious formulas it's possible to find in Rowling's story telling becomes a bit more forgivable. Come on Lezard, lighten up: lie back and enjoy the ride. Or at least stop treating Rowling's writing as if she's claiming to be the next Virginia Woolf - she's not.

Saturday, 14 July 2007

Preparatory

Indulging the inner child is always fun - and today I've been doing it big time! Well, I've just been reading something that probably better suits my real intellectual level (that is, low). Harry Potter!

There's a bit of a Potter glut at the moment, with the 5th film very recently out and the 7th and final (oh please final!) book out on Saturday. Not that I'm counting the days or anything. Look, there's an excuse, I'm a Potter Child - when the first book, HP & the Philosopher's Stone came out, I was the same age as Harry. That matters. Anyway, it's the 5th book, HP & the Order of the Phoenix I've been galloping through this afternoon, in preparation for seeing the film sometime this week. The films are great but they don't do the books justice, as they tend to leave great gaping holes where Rowling lovingly wrote explanations...it's annoying, so I curb the annoyance by reminding myself of the details pre-film. It's damage limitation.

People often ask me what I think of the Potter books, and it's invariably a slightly awkward conversation. They seem to think that because I study Real Literature (old books 'n' stuff), I will (a) not read 'popular' books or (b) look down on them but read them anyway, frowning and moaning. So the question is almost always asked apologetically, which is a bit sad. And then it's my turn to be trapped - either I say that I don't like the books, in which case I'm an academic snob and not open to anything fun/popular (and dismissing or rubbishing their literary taste into the bargain); or I say I do like them, in which case my studying Literature somehow becomes void and a sham because I can't tell the difference between Shakespeare and Rowling (in their minds). Obviously all this awkwardness and over-thinking is avoided if whoever's asking doesn't know that I study (a) English, (b) at Cambridge - a fact I keep as quiet as possible, so easy conversations do sometimes happen (not often enough, sadly). With the final HP book very much on its way, it seems time to come clean:

I'M CRUMPETTY AND I LIKE *HARRY POTTER*!

Rowling has got a fantastic imagination, and she does great stuff with it. The plot of every one of the books is gripping, and I want to know what happens next. And that last is vital. I'm not reading HP for a Literary buzz; I'm reading it because it involves a great yarn. Good against evil for kids, but with the dark bits left in. It's not patronising, nor moralising, nor stodgy. The writing quality has markedly improved since the 1st book, which is an interesting development to trace in itself - for starters, Rowling finally seems to have got a handle on her discourse markers ("NO!", "roared Harry", " shuffled Ron", "squawked Hermione", "warned Hagrid"...it's calmed down now, thankfully, and an unobtrusive "said" is used more often). Some of the writing can be really powerful, and other bits not so. But the urge to turn the page to see what happens next is huge. She can tell a story. And that's what matters in this kind of book. It will be good to see if she turns her hand to another style post-Potter, and if she carries it off. I hope she does (both) - it would be a shame to be a seven-part one-trick pony.

Have I ordered my copy of the 7th book, HP & the Deathly Hallows? Yep, of course! And I'll spend next weekend locked in my room, away from telephone, internet or annoying fast-reading children who might talk, within my earshot, about what happens at The End. Am I ashamed of this? No. Though, just in case I should be ashamed, I'll confess that I read HP & the Philosopher's Stone in Latin. Less impressively, I tried it in Russian but got about as far as a dolphin in the Sahara. So, onwards, Chapter 1 -

"Dominus et Domina Dursley, qui vivebant in aedibus Gestationis Ligustrorum numero quattuor signatis, non sine superbia dicebant se ratione ordinaria vevendi uti neque se paenitere illius rationis. in toto orbe terrarum vix credas quemquam esse minus deditum rebus novis et arcanis, quod ineptias tales omnino spernebant..."

(Who on earth thought it was a good idea to translate HP "et Philosophi Lapis" into Latin?! Fantastic, and mad!)

Friday, 13 July 2007

Divination

A divining wooden leg; it twitches and pulls when it finds underground water - funky, eh? It's one of the few constant possessions of Henry Smart, the linchpin of Roddy Doyle's novel, A Star Called Henry - first volume of The Last Roundup. I bought the book months ago from the Oxfam bookshop in Cambridge but didn't get round to reading it until the train journey this last weekend (though I've just finished it in the comfort of home). Doyle's style is very readable. It's not (usually) clunky, and he doesn't push effects too far. He's a master of dialogue and idiosyncratic turn of phrase. He is funny, with a darkly aware edge. He is not too explicit, nor obstructively obscure. Vitally, I think, the characters come through as a much stronger presence than their creator. It's the same in The Woman Who Walked into Doors, a very different but very strong little book.

A Star Called Henry traces the main-man's life from birth through to the end of his teenage years. Narrated by Henry himself (even at birth, which is a bit weird - though somehow it works as Henry possesses a self-knowledge and assurance that's convincing enough for anything to be possible), his story develops alongside the rise of Irish nationalism and the increasing activity of the I.R.A. It helps to know something about Irish history (and geography, to an extent) in order to follow the plot. Henry is one of those people who is involved in everything, but not quite important enough to get the credit for it. He's a vital shadow, invisible but essential. Doyle treads a thin line between historical inaccuracy and plausible happenings, though I think the balance works out because Henry does manage to stay on the right side of obscure. But in that way Doyle gives his very ordinary man extraordinary characteristics and roles. It's good. It's funny, sad, humanitarianly terrifying and literarily engaging. And I come back to the dialogue - Doyle is one of the best speech-writers I've read, because his characters don't say too much (a flaw of so many writers, who put their own words and plots into characters' mouths for too long a time. It becomes unsustainable).

It's tempting to write a bit about the plot because its historical basis is really interesting, but I won't - spoilers are annoying, and reading a good book for pleasure for the first time should, I think, involve surprise and discovery. So read it. I'll seek out the second volume at some point (Oh, Play That Thing), and hopefully will enjoy it as much - given the consistence of Doyle's writing, I see no reason why I won't. There was a stretch of about 30 pages towards the end of the book where the subject, writing style (yes, I mean syntax) and even the words came together in an unfortunate predictable clump; but that was it - and 30 duff pages out of over 300 really isn't a bad tally (and they're all together, so it's over fast!). I'm not sure why that happened (though it's easy to see how it did). I think one of the reasons I like his writing is because he deals with difficult topics and people whilst neither making them trite nor too heavy; he is a fantastic writer, good enough to get lost in the first time and to be gainfully revisited, but not so challenging as to be too-slow progress. S. Clayton Moore claims that this is "not a beach read", but I beg to differ - I think it's a perfect beach read, for those who like their books, and aren't so fond of beaches.

Friday, 6 July 2007

Tripartite

Finished Michael Cunningham's Specimen Days last night, which will elate CEH because she's been nagging me to read it for months. It's certainly like nothing else I've read. It does some new stuff, and does it in a new way. Not so sure about the insistent Walt Whitman theme going on, though; and I have to admit that when a line of Emily Dickinson appeared from apparently nowhere I groaned a bit and begged it to stop. The description is very detailed, possibly too much so - Cunningham would make a brilliant film director, probably, with his eye for accuracy. He'd be perfectionist and dictatorial, but a damned good film would come out of it. But his description tells too much and just doesn't leave anything much to be imagined, except for the psychology of the characters, who are - without exception - weird.

Saying that, any book that brings together the industrial age, terrorism and an android in love with an alien lizard is probably worth a look - particularly because it doesn't feel as strange as it should. The android/lizard part actually made the most sense. It definitely took me longer than usual to get into the book and what it was doing (and I'm still not entirely sure of that), which isn't necessarily a bad thing; and I enjoyed it more as it progressed (which probably says more about my being unsettled at the beginning than about the book itself).

It was a thought-provoking read, though. Maybe it doesn't quite work, but it's cleverly different, and a mainly enjoyable way of spending a few hours.

Thursday, 5 July 2007

Miseducation (i)

There will be more on this, no doubt. But briefly,

I've been reading Aristotle's Poetics and the experience has been most frustrating; not the text so much (I've not finished it yet), but the process of reading it. What's bugging me is the fact that Aristotle's 'views' about Tragedy are talked about all over the place (well, not normally in the canned veg isle of the supermarket*, but you know what I mean), incorrectly. I don't mean incorrectly in the sense of 'there are lots of interpretations and this is the one I choose'; incorrectly like 'I don't know there are any interpretations. This is what it means.'

Probably annoyed about this because I thought I vaguely understood the basic concepts behind Aristotelian tragedy, but quite evidently that's not true. What seems to have happened is that I was taught about "Aristotle" at skool by people who almost certainly hadn't read Poetics, and they were probably taught by people who hadn't read it either, and so on. So there was me thinking I had a clue, but I don't: what I 'know' is at best an offensively over-simplified and at worst totally WRONG version of a Chinese Whisper that may once have been about Aristotle. Which is very annoying. So far, every 'standard' piece of tragic terminology (mimesis, hamartia, katharsis, pathos, praxis, etc.) I've come across in this text (and its comprehensive introduction by Malcom Heath) has meant either something different to that I was taught, or something so ambiguous or fluid or contextually-dependent that my 'definition' of it is absurdly out of whack. Bummer. My own fault - should have read the text itself long ago.

But it is very annoying that, at skool, kids are taught a weird mixture of lies and semi-truths, and almost always second-hand. Either give them the original texts (or scientific experiments, or whatever medium we're dealing with) and help them draw their own conclusions about stuff (if they're way-out, well, that's what Teacher's for); or only 'teach' them things they're actually capable of understanding (and it's not for some ludicrously out-of-touch government department run by an economist of all people to state what exactly it is kids of different ages might or might not be capable of understanding). It's irritating that 16-yr olds are told that electrons do one thing, and then when they start their AS Levels at 17 they are told almost the opposite; by the time they get to A Level, electrons probably don't exist, or something. Okay, so sometimes stuff has to be simplified - but at least tell them that what they're being taught is more an analogy than fact. And when it comes to literature/texts, doesn't it make more sense to avoid imposing complicated theoretical theories (i.e. Aristotle's, in this case) if it's deemed that the theories proper are way above the students' abilities? Why pay lip service to it at all?

Pah. Excuse the grousing, but I've got to go and figure out Aristotle. Again. Properly, this time.

********************

*ISLE?! What kind of word is isle?! It should be pronounced 'eyes-ull' or 'eyes-lee'. The more I look at it the weirder it is, and I'm not sure any more if it's the right word at all. Isle. The OED doesn't mention anything about supermarkets.**

**Yes, um...aisle. THAT would explain why it looked wrong! Duh.

Wednesday, 4 July 2007

Condensation

The raison d'etre of the Bible, as far as I can make out, is one- or two-fold:
(1) To tell a great set of stories,
(2) To make us think at least twice about Divinity, humanity and what might be between them.

Problem is, it's a very long text and hardly anyone ever bothers to read it (including, rather ridiculously and worryingly, Christians). Luckily, though, there are plenty of summaries, sections and condensations of the Bible on the market for everyone who wants to get a good idea of what's going on in the Book without having to take a sabbatical. One such condensation is The 100-Minute Bible, by Michael Hinton. Sadly, it's a bit rubbish. It advances neither of the two probably essential things above - the fantastic stories are flatly and sketchily conveyed, and religious or spiritual awe, thoughtfulness and/or interest are entirely absent. It manages to make the Creation, Abraham's almost-sacrifice and - even - the coming of Christ almost negligible. Nothing is explained (it isn't really in the Bible, either, but at least there's almost always a good back story to get to grips with so an explanation can always be deduced), and there's just a lot of thwarting of intentions and forgiving of actions without any reason why that might be appropriate.

This little pamphlet is very well intentioned, but neither tells a good story (despite having the best original material) nor makes God or Christ out to be particularly worth following. It is definitely a text intended (or at least it's only good) for people who are (a) already very familiar with the majority of the stories and (b) already convinced. Beyond that, though, it neither tells a good yarn nor goes into any kind of theological detail (which is a shame, as that's where the thoughts and questions lie).

If you want a good version of the stories, and they really are good, I reckon the best bet is to get a children's Bible. You know the kind - with corny and mutedly-coloured illustrations of shepherds with tea-towels on their heads. And if you want the theology, there are, I very much hope, some good condensations of the text out there - but until I stumble across it (or someone recommends one), I'll be sticking with the good old King James version.

Having said that, if you really do want an extraordinarily general overview, The 100-Minute Bible is better than nothing - it really does take about 100 minutes (and there's even a large-print version available if you feel your eyesight will hinder your speedy reading).