Showing posts with label University. Show all posts
Showing posts with label University. Show all posts

Saturday, 6 October 2007

"Is nothing sacred?!"

This cry went up in a class this week.

We were using Alice in Wonderland as a springboard text to discuss other things, but there was some serious objection to 'studying' (that is, rigorous questioning, finding out, and thinking about) a book that people had read as young (ish) children. The idea behind the objection, I think, was a horror that the original childhood impressions of the magical tale might be overwritten with the intrusion of adult eyes; the child's brain had been put in a sparkly pink box (or perhaps a more fitting slightly sinister one, given the weirdness of Alice) and was Not To Be Touched.

The Annotated Alice text exacerbated this problem - it's a fantastic and eclectic peering at Carroll's stories through every conceivable kind of eyes - the historical, the mathematical and physical, the cultural, the literary, the adult...But this was, it seemed, just too much information; too intrusive, too questioning, too learned and - God forbid! - perhaps even reading too much into the stories. Hang on a minute, isn't that the line Literature students (of all levels of experience and competence) walk along all the time? But because this text was in some way held sacred, because of childhood experience, the tolerence level dropped completely - 'You are not touching this text, this memory', Tolerence hissed, 'It's mine. My precious...' (Gollum was there too).

I have to admit I was irritated, because - when it comes to the study of Literature (and other things) - I do not think that anything should be protected from questioning. Nothing is sacred when it comes to academia (however microscopically tiny that academia might be). I'm here to ask questions, and to keep on answering them until something relents, or I realise it's a stupid question, or I die. I am not here to pussy-foot around people's fluffy constructions of what they think a book was about once. That is not at all interesting.

There is something intensely annoying about Arts students (in this sense, Literature, Music and Art) who will only go as far as - or are content to stop at - a feeling about something. I'm not denying that certain arts can make humans react in an emotional (or irrational, though I'm not using those two things synonymously) way, but I am saying that that is absolutely not what studying the arts is about. Or, if it is, I'm definitely doing the wrong thing. The absence of a desire to scrutinise is incomprehensible, to me, in people who are otherwise enviably bright. If they want to hold onto a cute idea of what certain texts are, it's perhaps questionable whether they're studying the right subject. Or maybe I'm studying the wrong one. Why not give Lolita or Bleak House to a kid, ask them what it's about, and leave it at that? Because that doesn't work. Et voila, nor does that attitude to Alice. Grow up - or at least be open to the possibility that there might be a giant rabbithole even in adult life.

Thursday, 27 September 2007

Nonsenses, plural.

One annoyance:
Why can't politicians just answer the occasional question with a Yes or a No, if one of those will suffice? That party politics has obscured sense is quite evident when a question such as "Do you agree with this very common-sense and really quite true thing?" is answered with equivocation, evasion, and another question.
I wake up to the Today Programme, which is most definitely the best reportage around, but it also has the unusual ability to get me riled before 6.30am. Impressive.

On a completely different note:
You know it's a good beginning of term when the first academic emails you receive include instructions to (i) Read Lewis Carroll, and (ii) Write an essay on a subject that includes ducks in hats.
We have lift off!

Thursday, 13 September 2007

In which single-word subjects cease.

It seems the best way to get through academic work (as well as being the best way for me to retain it), is to chat about it with people. Really, that's the only way anything gets anywhere. And it exercises the vocal chords, too -- going days without speaking to anyone does happen on occasion, but then re-entering the social world is something of a stressful experience.

Why say this now? Mainly because I've recently been exchanging emails with a couple of People Wot Read. I'd got a bit stuck with the Interminable Essay and my ideas were going round and round but not turning off anywhere, and they've really helped -- not because they know more about the subject (for once), but because they ask good questions. It's all about the questions. Questions from people who know more about it are scary, and serve their very handy purpose -- but that's for later; at the moment, to thrash an idea out in its preliminary stages, just 'innocent' questions often do the trick. More often than not it just seems to involve defining and refining the terms -- just as well, really, or I'd never make any sense.

Talking to the cat is also good. He is very patient, and pretends to understand (or pretends not to -- not quite sure which). Though the fact his favourite toy is one of my old socks probably doesn't say much for his intelligence. Never mind; I was rather fond of that sock too.

Friday, 31 August 2007

Gaps

Well, it appears what happens when Crumpetty gets really busy is...gaps. Big ones. Expect more. Never mind. Some things:

1) Attempting to read Rubin's The Hollow Crown was once more not successful (tried last year, too), and I'll probably give up. It's is not the best book about the Middle Ages, and made me a bit cross. Facts have a habit of being incredibly boring and unmemorable unless extremely carefully (and skilfully) presented, and that's unfortunately what happens in this book. I'm not one to shirk a challenge (unless it involves roller-coasters or shellfish), but I've decided there are better books about similar things. Such as...

2) ...Alison Weir's biography of Isabella, which is excellent. Weir has written a lot - on the bookshelves her output volume visually compares to that of Antonia Fraser (and they both write on very similar things, which might make for interesting comparison some time). Weir constructs biography and pieces together history very cleverly, and although her texts are laden with facts (with even brief endnotes coming close to 100 pages) the writing never feels heavy, confusing or dull. She weaves a good story; and although liberties are taken to bend [lack of] evidence to her will, it's not too annoying. I've just got hold of Eleanor of Aquitaine, too, and look forward to reading it. She's very recently branched out into historical fiction for the first time, with Innocent Traitor, centred around Lady Jane Grey - there's a possibility this might soon(ish) become a TV drama, so watch this space!

3) A week in very soggy Cambridge, hidden in cosy libraries and quiet spots. With endless thanks to LJJ for being a wonderful work companion, even (especially?) when we haven't a clue what each other is talking about! Some work needed a bit of a kick-start and that seemed a good place to do it. Lots of fun, and I managed to have An Idea - which so far has been resilient to crushing. It's probably only a matter of time until the Inevitable Problem occurs, but there is hope! A little grouse, though: people who write in library books. Little marks/comments/pictures in margins are fine, but one reader (and it was one) scribbled his (and it was most definitely a 'his') way through two entire volumes of a biography I was trying to read - this amounted to about 900 pages of MESS. Some paragraphs were unreadable because of his enthusiasm. Enough already.

4) I've come across an author who manages, quite uncannily, to write frighteningly relevant texts. The sentences seem to encapsulate everything that matters, and everything that doesn't. Not going to say who it is, or which books, because that would reveal more about my way of thinking about the world and myself than I will ever admit. I am curious to know if I feel the same way about the books in twenty years...Is this simply indicative of where I'm at now? Or what I fundamentally am? Presumably if the effect is indelible I'll remember to revisit the words to find out.

Tuesday, 14 August 2007

Justifiable

Work-avoidance is at its best served warm and justifiable - and as one of those lucky people who is interested in almost anything, justification is generally close to hand. Two things keeping me from being Little Miss Efficient today (whilst simultaneously teaching me some genuinely useful things):

1) Practicing reading Early-Modern scripts and manuscripts online. This is one of the most thoughtfully and effectively presented websites I've seen - it's fantastic! The idea is that one might learn and practice reading ye olde handwritings and scribal scratchings by following an impeccably designed and managed set of 'lessons', in which texts of differing complexities are transcribed. The site is maintained by Andrew Zurcher, who knows his and everyone else's stuff - an invaluable site for all Spenser nuts is also maintained by him (without which my Renaissance reading would [have] be[en] all the more anaemic). The handwriting site is an example of how the 'net can and should be put to best effect. That and YouTube, obviously.

2) First there was Pepys, now there's Roger Morrice. Well, not so much "now" as "there was also" - he's well dead. But a compatriot diary to Pepys' is very welcome; he's cited so much that it's good to have another text to go to, similar in form but different in content. This is fairly exciting, given I can already spend hours buried in a volume of Ypesp. It's always 'relevant', because I'm always reading something from the period (or thereabouts) - perfect procrastination, and with bonus educational benefits. A bit more information: here. When Newnham Library acquires the Morrice, that much less Real Work will get done - probably ought to pre-empt that by working now. Probably...

Saturday, 11 August 2007

Miscalculation

It took me two days rather than one to get to the end of Richard III's reign - but what's one more day when this project has run a week over already? Actually, I'm not quite going to stop yet - though I've finished the 'learning' part of things for now - next stop is Miri Rubin's The Hollow Crown: A History of Britain in the late Middle Ages. Nothing like a bit of immediate consolidation...or it might be procrastination, but I'm not really sure what from, given that my dissertation's going to have its very own University Library Time next week! All this reading is highly relevant to the Medieval Lit Paper we'll be doing next term, but it feels like I'm indulging my fascination with hi-stories (or, in later periods, His-Tories) rather than Proper Books. Still, more than enough time for that, always.

What's got me gripped about this whole thing is the variation in reports of the period (say, mid-13th century till end of the 15th). There are inevitably big gaps in evidence, and so much of what we 'know' is formed by propaganda of the various factions - like the stories about Isabella (Edward II's queen), or Margaret of Anjou (Henry VI's queen), or Joan of Arc. It's not all about the women - Richard III is a weird and wonderful case in point there, and Henry V - but the woman are particularly interesting because they don't often speak for themselves. There are some letters - about which I know very little, and I've no idea how much they say - but the overwhelming majority of the Middle Ages is written by men. The same can be said for later periods, but far less so - from the 16th century aristocratic women start writing and existing (and sponsoring) much more, and though there are serious limitations those women have at least gained a kind of retrospective freedom: we can hear them. Some might have been respected by their contemporaries (Magdalene Herbert, for example - the poet George Herbert's mother, famous in her own right), but many were ignored or ridiculed or excluded (Margaret Cavendish might take some or all of those titles). The difference being that, however they were perceived at the time, their written words have given them a posterity and a chance at being re-evaluated by subsequent generations. The persons of Medieval women are much quieter, and much more dependent on their contemporary menfolk for their reputations. Never a good idea.

A pretty good book for a starting point is Mark Ormrod's The Kings and Queens of England. Each of the royal Houses constitutes a chapter, and each chapter is taken by a different academic. There is some pronoun confusion (is she the sister of him, or of him? Or the daughter of him?), which often happens when a writer knows far more about the subject than their reader. Ho hum - only a minor annoyance, and the gaps have been filled in from elsewhere. It's a densely written book, which is good for saving trees, but less good for a nice casual reading book - not a beach-read, unless you have an elephantine (or professorial) memory!

Saturday, 4 August 2007

Extension

Is it just me, or does the idea of carting dead animals infected with Foot 'n' Mouth Disease across the country - from their farms in Surrey to the incineration point in Somerset - seem counterintuitive? It's not the most instinctive way to control the spread of a virus! I'm sure they know what they're doing, it just seems a little odd. As does the irony that the outbreak possibly derives from the Pirbright laboratories, in which scientists develop vaccines for such diseases. Ooops. Their little motto is painfully wrong at the moment, too - "Good science, Useful science"...ahem, Deadly Science...
If it were seven years since the last outbreak I'd go on about Biblical pestilence again, but it was only six so I won't. (I don't really think it's a plague sent by God - though what do I know? - but as I briefly mentioned yesterday that's what I was reading about. Tangential point of interest: in Leviticus 14:44, simple mildew is described as "fretting leprosy", so if there's any green mould climbing your walls your house has a plague. I like the idea of building surveyors looking for brick-leprosy instead of damp rot, there's something as dramatic as house prices about it).

********************
And the Education rant of the day. The front page of today's Telegraph finally reports what we knew was on its way, the changing (again) of the A Level system. The fundamentals of what's being said are: the current system doesn't stretch the brightest students; new-style exams will cover 4 units instead of the current 6 (more depth, less breadth); an A* grade will be introduced for results above 90%; students will be expected to complete an 'extended project' (like in the International Baccalaureate). There is more to the new system than simply this, but it gets complicated (and detailed) very quickly, so I'll keep it at this for now. These changes are set to come in from 2008.
Much of what's being done is okay, or at least it's well-intentioned (often just the best of a bad job, though), and of course there is no perfect system for everybody - particularly not in a culture obsessed with everybody achieving according to the same standards. (1) They are right in saying that the system as is doesn't stretch the brightest students, and at the moment they are left to challenge themselves or Lady Luck finds them a fantastic teacher/mentor who prevents them from going off the rails with boredom and introduces them to new ideas. (2) Although the intention is to encourage greater depth in doing just 4 units, I suspect that by studying fewer subjects there will be far less accessible cross-referencing, which will ultimately lead to anaemic thinking and examination responses. The consequence will be, I think, increasingly narrow-minded, bored and unaware students. (3) The introduction of an 'A*' we've seen before, and it's an integral part of the GCSE system now. I'd argue for harsher marking and an upping of expectations, rather than the weak filtering that the A* will cause. Stop pussy-footing around the issue and pretending that everyone should be allowed to get A's and above. Make A's more difficult to achieve.

Finally, (4) the International Bacalaureate-like 'extended project', which is where I start gnashing my teeth. Instead of sliding along trying not to look like they're aware of the IB, why don't the Educationy governmenty people just introduce the IB into our mainstream schools? If that sounds like a wild idea to you, get a life. It seems like an incredibly straightforward option, and I have no idea why people aren't taking it. Maybe the same mindset as holding onto the Pound Sterling, though with little historical interest nor economic problems. The A Level system is a broken cobbled-together mishmash of diktat after diktat, respected by few and struggled against by hundreds of thousands of students every year. It is a mess, and unfixable without major alterations - alterations policy-makers are not willing, or not able, to effect. So it's broke, and we can't fix it. The IB, on the other hand, is continuing to have great success and is well-respected across the globe, and schools in Britain are increasingly adopting it as an alternative - or sole - curriculum. It's really good. It's not perfect, but it works. It challenges the most talented students, a fact indicated by the offers Oxford and Cambridge give IB students every year: marked out ouf 45, the standard offer from these two universities is between 38 and 42 points, with the Higher Level subjects requiring between 7,6,6 and 7,7,7. Compare this to A Level offers, which are almost always AAA or more.

The IB covers a broader range of subjects in greater depth. It doesn't sacrifice breadth for hoped-for 'depth' (cf: imminent changes in A Level system) - they study more. It's challenging for the most able students; respected and recognised world-wide; the government wouldn't be able to embarrassedly fix results because our examinations scripts would be sent all over the place for marking. It would require teachers to completely revamp their syllabuses and methods, but if the sweeping changes claimed by this 'new' system are really that sweeping then teachers are going to have a hellish settling-down period anyway, so why not go the whole hog with a system that has been tried and tested? They'd have far more fun teaching it. From what I've seen of IB students, they are quite simply better educated - that to me screams volumes, and it's not just because they all seem to have gone to private schools of one kind or another.

IB, please, Education Balls.

(I did A Levels, by the way).

Wednesday, 25 July 2007

Loitering

Though being away from University does suck quite a lot, one thing has made all these months entirely worth it - the space and time to re-read. Of course I'm looking forward to going back (9 weeks and 3 days, though I'm not counting...), but being able to read and re-read has been a luxury for which I'm thankful - Tripos seems to give no quarter, normally. People don't usually believe me when they find out the incalculably vast majority of my 'Literature' reading has been done in the last two years (since starting my course), but it's true - I read fiction until I was about 13, and then read mainly Philosophy, History and Politics, as well as Biology and Physics (lots of Physics) until my university interviews loomed four years later, which point seemed timely to start reading fiction again. (In case you're confused, English wasn't quite my intended career path until just before the university applications had to be finished). I'm not at all bothered by this fact, though it's very often apparent that I'm not as well read as most other Englings, because the historical/political/philosophical background always comes in handy. But it's a fact nevertheless.

With Tripos put aside for a while, then, reading could commence. All that funky sideways stuff that comes up in the course of the Papers but which never gets read because there just isn't time. Making up for lost time. I'm helped and hindered by an insatiable curiosity, with which I got tangled in Frontispiece (June). I've just been able to read anything and everything, and for once really follow up any 'Further Reading' recommendations in the backs of books. It's exciting, really. Exciting and infuriating (despite having unintended time, there still isn't enough of it to get through everything. Obviously). So I've been able to re-read the fairytales I should have been read when I was wee (I never was read them, but got round to doing it myself a few years later - but it means that Cinderella and Ugly Duckling and their ilk aren't part of my unconscious. That may well be for the better - I'm not scared of midnight, nor hopeful about ugliness); and I've been able to read more Beckett. Much more Rushdie and Eco, at last. And lots of the things so many people think are fundamental (and they are, in a way, but they weren't my building-blocks), like the Just So Stories, which I'm sure are much more interesting when read after Conrad, rather than when 6 years old - or at least that's my excuse, now. There have been some new discoveries, too: Auden and Dryden, amongst others. Reading (and the all-important re-reading) more texts by already-discovered and loved authors, in such abundance, is an unexpected treat I won't soon forget.

This might sound like I'm saying goodbye to that luxury, and I suppose in a way I am as Tripos is beginning to get its hooks back into me, and there's a dissertation that needs writing and - more pressingly - reading for. I love Tripos: without it I wouldn't have had such a want to read and read and read; but space away from it has somehow brought it, and what it stands for, closer.

Here seems as good a place as any to list some texts. These are my life-changers so far (though most good books have a very real impact, these have somehow significantly changed my thinking rather than just adding to it). If you don't like lists, look away now - I just feel like writing one! In no particular order:


  • A Room of One's Own, Woolf -- I've read this enough that now I just open it and read it whenever I'm restless or frustrated. It's calming and motivating, and really very funny. I love it for my being able to get something new from it every time. Every Newnhamite should be given a copy of it when they join the College. Maybe I'll start that tradition...
  • Paradise Lost, Milton -- It's beautiful, multi-dimensional, infinitely contentious and my 'Desert Island Book'. I can't get over how near-perfect the poetry is, and how vital almost every word. First read it in 6th Form, and it's another of those I can always open and enjoy.
  • The Good Soldier, Ford Madox Ford -- Encountered this, as a two-page extract, in a 1st yr class. I was too curious to let it lie, so read it and againandagainandagain...This wonderful writer is now the subject of my dissertation, but I really need to get past the "This dude does dead good" stage of the argument!
  • Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit, Winterson -- The themes of this mattered first, and it was only later I realised how well the thing is written. This one was read when I was about 12, and it couldn't have been better timed. It was lent to me by someone who knew me better than I did, then.
  • The Satanic Verses, Salman Rushdie -- The beginning of my interest in Literature, rather than just books. It's almost certainly this that got me doing English at Newnham, so I'm all for the man's Knighthood.
  • The Qur'an -- I read this for the first time a couple of months ago. It'll stay with me. Though I wish I could read Arabic...
  • The Henrys (IV, V & VI), Shakespeare -- Pre-University I was scared of what Shakey stood for, and avoided him. Faced with a whole term of his writing in 2006 I decided to just jump right in with the plays that frightened me most and see what happened, and I fell in love. These plays are what did it for me.
  • Fear and Trembling, Kierkegaard --The beginning of a new world, when I was 13.
  • The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock, Eliot -- I've always struggled with poetry; I love taking it apart and seeing how it works, but I don't often feel it. This is probably the first poem that grabbed something sinewy inside me and pulled until I had to give in.

Good books leave themselves in you somehow. Some deposit themselves as whispers of quotations that catch you unawares (like J. Alfred Prufrock); others as tableaus stuck in monochrome (The Handmaid's Tale, particularly, did this. I re-read it yesterday and re-visited all the old pictures, amending some too). Some of them niggle like an Ohrwurm, like this irritating song by 'Peter, Bjorn & John' (I challenge you to listen to it all the way through and then not whistle it...) - Fear and Trembling did this to me. Others draw you back to them with an invisible piece of thread they tied round you at first reading - Room of One's Own always tempts me from the bookshelf. Known books never disappoint, never betray; they change, as we do, but that's okay, that's layering rather than abandonment.

Friday, 20 July 2007

Cartography

I was born in 28, brought up in 154, go to university in 209, and my last holiday was in 160. What? They're the reference numbers of Ordnance Survey maps, one of my favourite set of objects in the world. Maps are beautiful. Staring at them for ages; studying their contours and colours; seeing the real geography in my mind from the information on the flat page; planning walking, running or cycling routes; finding perfect picnic spots. A good map is the world in miniature and symbols, and getting lost in them is a perfect way to forget reality for a while.

Most of my Cambridge-based exploring so far has been deliberately accidental: I've set off, on foot or bike, and just moved around the area. Almost always ending up happily lost, and quite honestly I never know where I've been. It doesn't matter, really. But it's annoying when I find something nice but can't go back there because "There" doesn't have a name or direction. Worse, I'm directionally useless in cities and towns. Put me in a wood or on a hill and I'm normally fine: towns are a mystery. Deciding enough was enough and that next year will involve Proper Exploration, buying the OS map for the Cambridge area seemed a good plan. Anyone who regularly uses maps, though, will know that this was a stupid thing to set out to do. In the OS world, there is rarely a single map for somewhere - with the same regularity as falling toast landing butter-side down, the place you're interested in exploring (from) is on the edge of a map. And hwaet! this venture landed butter-side down. Exploring the Cambridge surroundings requires three maps - three! That's two more than is convenient! Going to Ely needs maps 209 and 226; same goes for Newmarket and Mildenhall. Huntingdon requires 225. How annoying is that?

Still, I suppose it means more lovely maps to look at. Not that Cambridge affords the most aesthetic interest, given there are no hills...

Sunday, 1 July 2007

Hysterias (ii)

University applications. It's that time of year when Sixth Formers start thinking about them. Well, actually, there are several times in the year when they do - but post-exams (now) is one of them. (The others are in Sept/Oct, UCAS deadlines; Nov/Dec, interviews; Dec/Jan, post-interviews...brief respite until May/June, thence exams; August, A Level results. This leaves four months when they're not thinking about them). Lots of earnest questions being asked, and they land in my inbox by the dozen - questions about Cambridge, about the English Tripos, about Newnham College. I like answering them, and it's only very occasionally that a vitriolic response wants to escape into the tippytappy keyboard from my fingertips (normally in response to "Is Newnham full of lesbians?") - and the causticity has been suppressed thus far. But there is something a bit wonky about the whole thing...

For starters, there is an utter lack of common sense in about 70% of questions asked - or it might in many cases be called laziness. The University and College prospectuses give much (though not all) the information needed. Dear applicants, please read them! The various prospectuses sit as a pile on my desk and most often the direct answer to the question asked is contained within their slightly fishy-smelling pages. Though I have the advantage of knowing the system (and, by now, the page numbers for every answer possibly required, groan), it really isn't that hard to find what's needed - and a wee bit of initiative wouldn't be amiss in a Cambridge (or indeed university) applicant. Please?

The delicious main course of the affair is a more serious one. Misinformation and the dogged persistence of Oxbridge Myths (these latter are seriously tough cookies, some of them have been told for over 100 years!). The Access & Admissions people (various academics, staff and students) work very hard to distribute up-to-date and genuinely helpful information, but it seems not to permeate into the application atmosphere. It's not just the completely mad stuff - like the idea that setting fire to your interviewer's hair will make their boring day more interesting and thereby gain you a place at the University - it's a bit more sinister than that. The idea that if you attend your local comprehensive (or have a northern accent) you will instantly arouse dislike. The idea that if you go to a public school (or have a Home Counties accent) you will instantly arouse dislike. Or sport - competence at sports attracts suspicion (brawn and brains incompatible); incompetence at sport means instant rejection ("What? Not captain of the county lacrosse team? You miserable specimen!"). Naturally, the interviewers are out to get everyone. You have to be a certified genius to stand a chance. And once you're safely at the University you are chained to your desk for 10 hrs a day...or is it that everyone spends all their time in the bar, the work getting done magically by the telekinesis of genius? I can't remember - it's all got so complicated.
Anyway, there's still a huge volume of work to be done in this area - both in getting rid of any wobbly bits at the University end (the ethnic minorities and state vs. private school chestnuts are still hanging about), and in simply getting applicants to CALM DOWN. Just read a good book to take your mind off it all. Please?

A short but sweet dessert. The number of [potential] applicants who seem almost entirely disinterested in their subject (or any other subject) is scary. It's something that carries through to the University population proper too, to an extent. Yes, yes, I know it's not cool to say that Physics is Phun or that Readin' is Rockin', but a little enthusiasm would be nice. Please?

There's a lot of fun to be had answering the more sensible questions, though. Many of the more astute queries raise serious questions about the nature of education generally, and the UK university system entire. And there are gaps in the official information that need filling (there are probably things that can't 'officially' be said - like the fact that English is The Best Subject. It's absolutely true, but there's probably some rule that means it can't go on the front of all the prospectuses). It's just that after sifting through a silly number of emails today all asking some variation of, "If I don't own a business, captain a national sports team, sit on a board of trustees and play seven instruments, will I automatically be rejected?", it's time for a cuppa. The answer to that question (and the vast majority of its variants), by the way, is 'no'. As is the answer to the lesbian question.