Showing posts with label Rant. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rant. Show all posts

Saturday, 6 October 2007

"Is nothing sacred?!"

This cry went up in a class this week.

We were using Alice in Wonderland as a springboard text to discuss other things, but there was some serious objection to 'studying' (that is, rigorous questioning, finding out, and thinking about) a book that people had read as young (ish) children. The idea behind the objection, I think, was a horror that the original childhood impressions of the magical tale might be overwritten with the intrusion of adult eyes; the child's brain had been put in a sparkly pink box (or perhaps a more fitting slightly sinister one, given the weirdness of Alice) and was Not To Be Touched.

The Annotated Alice text exacerbated this problem - it's a fantastic and eclectic peering at Carroll's stories through every conceivable kind of eyes - the historical, the mathematical and physical, the cultural, the literary, the adult...But this was, it seemed, just too much information; too intrusive, too questioning, too learned and - God forbid! - perhaps even reading too much into the stories. Hang on a minute, isn't that the line Literature students (of all levels of experience and competence) walk along all the time? But because this text was in some way held sacred, because of childhood experience, the tolerence level dropped completely - 'You are not touching this text, this memory', Tolerence hissed, 'It's mine. My precious...' (Gollum was there too).

I have to admit I was irritated, because - when it comes to the study of Literature (and other things) - I do not think that anything should be protected from questioning. Nothing is sacred when it comes to academia (however microscopically tiny that academia might be). I'm here to ask questions, and to keep on answering them until something relents, or I realise it's a stupid question, or I die. I am not here to pussy-foot around people's fluffy constructions of what they think a book was about once. That is not at all interesting.

There is something intensely annoying about Arts students (in this sense, Literature, Music and Art) who will only go as far as - or are content to stop at - a feeling about something. I'm not denying that certain arts can make humans react in an emotional (or irrational, though I'm not using those two things synonymously) way, but I am saying that that is absolutely not what studying the arts is about. Or, if it is, I'm definitely doing the wrong thing. The absence of a desire to scrutinise is incomprehensible, to me, in people who are otherwise enviably bright. If they want to hold onto a cute idea of what certain texts are, it's perhaps questionable whether they're studying the right subject. Or maybe I'm studying the wrong one. Why not give Lolita or Bleak House to a kid, ask them what it's about, and leave it at that? Because that doesn't work. Et voila, nor does that attitude to Alice. Grow up - or at least be open to the possibility that there might be a giant rabbithole even in adult life.

Friday, 28 September 2007

Interventions

I wanted to write about the current situation in Burma at the moment, because it's frightening and big and all over the media. But it seems too big for me to get a handle on, so I'll take a more oblique look (that is, talk about something almost entirely different).

When things such as Burma's protests happen, something that comes up a lot is the idea of international intervention: just how much should the rest of the world do about something going on in another country? There are wars going on across the whole planet caused by one government's trying to intervene with another, or one group attempting to impose its idea of Right upon another. War is generally not a good thing, so we might say that extreme intervention (involving waging war) is Wrong (because it impacts too much upon people - civilians - who have no real power to change their country's situation). On the other hand, though, I do think that some things are just unacceptable and that a lack of intervention (of come kind) is reprehensible. Obviously this means I do not adhere to the belief that everyone should be able to do whatever the hell they like, regardless of the impact on other people - it's a possible standpoint but not, in my view, a valid one. I do, therefore, think that intervention (of some kind) is a necessity.

But when?

This is a bit twee, maybe, but that's not important. A very well-known poem by Martin Niemoller quietly highlights many problems:

First they came for the Jews
and I did not speak out
because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for the Communists
and I did not speak out
because I was not a Communist.
Then they came for the trade unionists
and I did not speak out
because I was not a trade unionist.
Then they came for me
and there was no one left
to speak out for me.

Of those "many", though, the one that interests me is the end result of the lack of intervention. Not really the fact that eventually "They" will come and get "me" (that doesn't really factor anywhere in my thinking about this, probably because I'm fortunate enough never to have been victimised in the large-scale way this poem is concerned with), but the downward slope, caused by lack of intervention, leading to the victory of "They".

So take a smaller example. In the pub last night there was a young Polish woman working behind the bar and a (probably) drunken bloke walked in and started hurling abuse at her (I say "probably" drunk, because it explains his disproportionate behaviour - though obviously doesn't justify it). This abuse centred on three traits: (1) Her professionalism [refusal to serve him because he was already pissed, and very rude]; (2) Her sex; (3) Her non-Englishness. The disagreement about (1) I can understand (if not sympathise with) - he was drunk, prior to his arrival, and wanted more alcohol; the abuse relating to (2) was offensive but could perhaps be passed off as just a standard way to insult women - it annoyed me, but only because it was generally insulting (i.e. he was drunk, and expressing himself in the coarsest way possible. Fine). But when he got onto (3) I decided that was enough; probably because it was, by then, personal to the person he was attacking. It seems a bit odd that (3) provoked me into action, despite the fact that what I have in common with her is (2). I'm not sure why that is.
This was all happening extremely loudly and quite physically, in a pub that was in complete silence otherwise (his shouting saw to that). So, at the point (3) reared its head, I got up and asked him to leave - which he did (though probably not because I asked him - he could easily have knocked me out, I don't have the figure of a bouncer...), after calling me a "Medieval whore"*.
None of this made me angry. What made me angry was the group of business 'gentlemen' standing around the bar the whole time this was going on, and not one of them said a word. They stood, glasses in hand (and sober), watching in silence. That was it, that was their reaction; to watch it. The ignorant, drunk, yelling bloke was just that (a fairly harmless, though volatile, arsehole) but the silentwatching 'gentlemen' were, to me, morally disgusting and socially dangerous. On the bloke's exit from the pub one of the besuited businessmen made some cute placatory remark to him -- WHY? (I actually think the answer to this is that he was scared of being hit). I hope at least one or two of those blokes feels suitably embarrassed that they didn't step in, even when it was beginning to get physical.

Was I overreacting? Should I have stood and let it happen like the others? Did I take too much of a risk? (Probably, physically speaking). Am I right in being furious about the others' apathy/cowardice? Is self-preservation more important? I believe in freedom of expression...but does that belief extend to expressing yourself in such an offensive and disruptive way (I was, after all, trying to enjoy a nice evening in the pub!)? Do I have any right to get on my moral high-horse? (Probably not) Why did it bother me anyway?

Lots of questions.
As I said above, I think intervention (of some kind) a necessity; a necessity, that is, for retaining a sense of our own principles. There comes a point where everyone will make a stand (even if only for themselves, eventually), and it is that point, I think, that helps define us. It's not a linear thing, and not everyone's priorities will be in the same area, but it's where we say "no", isn't it, that makes us more than automatons? The point at which I say "no" isn't necessarily a Right one, but I'm reassured that I at least have one. I suspect Stanley Milgram would have had something to say about those gentlemen-in-suits...oh wait, he already said it: we're screwed, probably.

Of course it's a whole different can of worms to ask how we know if our principles/interventions are the Right ones. If we follow a principle of luxurious self-gratification we'd take a different tack to someone upholding the importance of the biological (reproductive) imperative, or a societal ideal of one kind or another. Who's to say which is the Right one? For now, I'd just like to think that everyone has some kind of guiding principle - that would be a start.

-----------
* "Medieval whore" did make me laugh (though not at the time, as I was wondering at that instant if he was actually going to hit me). It's probably the best drunken insult I've heard - and a surprising one, given the 'type' of bloke it seemed to be coming from. I would perhaps have preferred "dissembling luxurious drab" (Troilus & Cressida), but beggars can't be choosers!

Sunday, 2 September 2007

Intolerability?

I've been thinking about the concept of tolerance recently, or more specifically the point at which things should or could become intolerable. Not the kind of 'tolerance' Slavoj Zizek refers to in his comment that 'Tolerance makes everything boring, we need more conflict!'; though he does have some very interesting things to say about political [in]tolerance and what that action/non-action/non-engagement (of any kind) means in the real world. 'Why is the proposed remedy tolerance', he asks, 'rather than emancipation, political struggle, even armed struggle?' (for more, you could look at this PDF - from which the latter quotation is lifted - although reading any Zizek is worth it, and more often than not raises similar themes). That type of tolerance is of course implicit in any notion of intolerance or - particularly - intolerability, but it's tangential rather than central to my musings.

No, what I'm wondering is possibly more personal, and more concerned with one's actions once we decide something is (comparatively speaking) intolerable. How is the 'intolerable' defined? Turning to the OED:

1) That cannot be tolerated, borne, or put up with; unendurable, unbearable, insupportable, insufferable:
(a) Physically
(b) Mentally or morally

My interest is in sense (b) - that of the mentally/morally intolerable.
The danger with words like this is to slip into hyperbole or overstatement. Doubtless I will, because very little is genuinely 'intolerable' - most things are, however unpleasantly, put-upable-with. In the case of physical pain, most often we lose consciousness or go into a deeper state of unconsciousness still and die; in the case of mental, the extreme includes going mad (a type of unconsciousness, or at least a different consciousness) or committing suicide.

Assuming that there is little we can do about the real mental intolerabilities, chemicals running rampant through our bodies and brains to an extent which no drugs or reason can touch, and that really cause madness in the sufferer - in which case that might be argued to be 'tolerable in a different state', as the mind is forced to entirely change in order to accommodate said rampant chemical or state; though of course if a complete and unalterable change must be implemented that probably means the thing that causes it really is intolerable, as if we can't keep some semblance of ourselves amidst our reaction we aren't really managing very well to do much but breathe and be an annoyance in society. So. Assuming that is the case, it's the moral intolerabilities that are interesting.

Essentially what I'm asking is, at what point do we stand up and say "No" to something we find abhorrent? When, "Stop"? When is the line crossed between personally offensive and societally worrying? Does one of these matter more than another? Who gets to deem something 'societally worrying', anyway? The government? (Hopefully not, or suicide really is the only option given I can't will myself mad). As is often the case, what provoked this train of thought was something superficially quite mild (though, as always, it boils down to The State Of The World etc.): The News. Media. Reportage.

I cannot stand watching the news. It makes me feel physically sick. Everything about it: the way the newsreaders speak; inane/insulting/ignorant questions asked of the 'roving reporters' or commentators; the images it's deemed fitting to show to accompany the godawful scripts; the intrusion of reporters/photographers into the lives of normal (or even not-so-normal) people; the priorities of headlines down to items less 'newsworthy'; the very concept of newsworthiness. I can't remember the last time I managed to watch the news without walking out in disgust (and it's always walking out or turning off - changing channel is never an option because I'm always too riled). If the ridiculous scripts don't get to me first, the images do: I find them disgusting, morally. I hate the desperate scrabble to be closest to the scene of the latest bombing or war (can't it be reported safely away from the flying mortars?); to be the first to interview the surviving relatives of a "tragedy" (sometimes they really are tragedies, but on most occasions the word is used by the media the situation is not Tragic - get a sense of proportion) with insulting questions - "How do you feel about losing your entire family in the fire?", "What do you think about the Islamic terrorists who killed your father?"...to take the most shocking pictures of things we can imagine quite well ourselves, thank you very much.

This has gone on for years. I keep up to date with things current and political by reading newspapers because - just about - I can filter through the crap at my own pace, and am not too often out-faced by the appalling presentation of the horrific state of the world as 'glamorous'. The financial pages are quite calming, I find - numbers, ups and downs, games of business. (Though in the recent stock market mess those boundaries became uncomfortably blurred). So I flick between 'real news' and finance to stay sane. I also refuse to have a 'regular' paper, and consequently rotate the main broadsheets more or less regularly. If a tabloid is around, I'll flick through it to see what's being said, but I will never buy one - they have too much money for their crimes already. Listening to Radio 4's Today is good, as there's rarely one person saying their thing for too long, and even if they are there's often someone there to argue with them. This doesn't stop the stupid questions being asked, but it does provide more real balance than any visually-broadcast programme (all of which are shorter).

The other worry with visual news is our desensitisation to those images, the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse (War, Famine, Pestilence & Death). When I watched the news regularly (I stomached it between the ages of about 14 and 17), I simply got used to it. Now, it repulses me - physically and morally - because I'm not used to it (and, now, refuse to get used to it), and probably because the boundaries of acceptability have also changed. I don't want to feel comfortable looking at these things; I don't want them to be in my face until I shrug and say "that's life" or "oh look there's another war"; I don't ever want to see those images on the screen, belittled already by stupid or badly-advised commentators and reporters, and to have a disinterest - caused by familiarity - enough to simply flick over the channel to watch something more interesting or entertaining.

The media, reportage, 'News', is something that makes me really and constantly angry. About other things - about education (a subject close to my heart, mind and irritation), religion, politics, people - about these things I get a wee bit cross, I might rant a bit and let off steam, I might occasionally let out a yell of frustration. But mostly these things annoy me because what they are (at any given time) doesn't make sense, or people aren't thinking practically or sensibly (ever the logician...). Few things anger me without fail, and I rarely fail to see the good in things. Except in this case (and maybe one other, but that's not coming into the equation here). I find this situation intolerable - I cannot accept it, I can't live with it, I can't get out of my head the staggeringly detrimental effect it must be having in so many ways. An immediate reaction is to avoid it, to avoid The News (particularly visual, remember) - but this isn't a solution; it's a bit like hiding under a bed when things are going wrong, as you remove yourself from the problem but don't remove the problem itself.

And I can't find a way away from that anger (or, for any length of time, its cause). I can't commit myself to changing the system, because to do that would necessarily mean getting actively involved with it - something I simply can't do. It's not like it's one-sided reporting I'm so against, so I can't set up a rival organisation in an attempt to squash it. My inclination, always, is to tolerate everything within reason, and when the edge of reason arrives to take positive steps to change the situation causing (or containing) the intolerable. Very often this is a practical solution, and remarkably easy to implement (on a small scale. I've not yet figured out how to stop people killing each other on a worldwide stage...). But with this I'm stuck: I can't tolerate it because I find it so unutterably wrong, but I can't find a way to solve the problem.
Which means, I suppose, that I'll have to live with its intolerability (that, or suicide). But that itself is tolerating it, isn't it? Or is anger, constant anger, enough to count as a stand against the intolerable? And is it our moral duty (in whatever sense you want to interpret that - I have my own way, you will have yours) to remove ourselves from the influence of that we find intolerable, or to stop it? If the former, suicide looks an attractive (theoretical) option; but I'm always inclined towards the latter - changing things that are wrong (I live in hope, you see...). But what if I believe I can't change that particular thing (assuming that's realism talking, not pessimism - a constant debate, that)?

It's all circular, curious and infuriating. Maybe the ultimate defence mechanism is to slide into a stupor of not caring (or a stupor of ineffective but self-righteous anger, naturally!)? Then nothing is intolerable except the immediately personal, in which case there is no 'moral duty' to do anything, and one may slip quietly into unconsciousness through madness or suicide.
I don't know.

Saturday, 4 August 2007

Extension

Is it just me, or does the idea of carting dead animals infected with Foot 'n' Mouth Disease across the country - from their farms in Surrey to the incineration point in Somerset - seem counterintuitive? It's not the most instinctive way to control the spread of a virus! I'm sure they know what they're doing, it just seems a little odd. As does the irony that the outbreak possibly derives from the Pirbright laboratories, in which scientists develop vaccines for such diseases. Ooops. Their little motto is painfully wrong at the moment, too - "Good science, Useful science"...ahem, Deadly Science...
If it were seven years since the last outbreak I'd go on about Biblical pestilence again, but it was only six so I won't. (I don't really think it's a plague sent by God - though what do I know? - but as I briefly mentioned yesterday that's what I was reading about. Tangential point of interest: in Leviticus 14:44, simple mildew is described as "fretting leprosy", so if there's any green mould climbing your walls your house has a plague. I like the idea of building surveyors looking for brick-leprosy instead of damp rot, there's something as dramatic as house prices about it).

********************
And the Education rant of the day. The front page of today's Telegraph finally reports what we knew was on its way, the changing (again) of the A Level system. The fundamentals of what's being said are: the current system doesn't stretch the brightest students; new-style exams will cover 4 units instead of the current 6 (more depth, less breadth); an A* grade will be introduced for results above 90%; students will be expected to complete an 'extended project' (like in the International Baccalaureate). There is more to the new system than simply this, but it gets complicated (and detailed) very quickly, so I'll keep it at this for now. These changes are set to come in from 2008.
Much of what's being done is okay, or at least it's well-intentioned (often just the best of a bad job, though), and of course there is no perfect system for everybody - particularly not in a culture obsessed with everybody achieving according to the same standards. (1) They are right in saying that the system as is doesn't stretch the brightest students, and at the moment they are left to challenge themselves or Lady Luck finds them a fantastic teacher/mentor who prevents them from going off the rails with boredom and introduces them to new ideas. (2) Although the intention is to encourage greater depth in doing just 4 units, I suspect that by studying fewer subjects there will be far less accessible cross-referencing, which will ultimately lead to anaemic thinking and examination responses. The consequence will be, I think, increasingly narrow-minded, bored and unaware students. (3) The introduction of an 'A*' we've seen before, and it's an integral part of the GCSE system now. I'd argue for harsher marking and an upping of expectations, rather than the weak filtering that the A* will cause. Stop pussy-footing around the issue and pretending that everyone should be allowed to get A's and above. Make A's more difficult to achieve.

Finally, (4) the International Bacalaureate-like 'extended project', which is where I start gnashing my teeth. Instead of sliding along trying not to look like they're aware of the IB, why don't the Educationy governmenty people just introduce the IB into our mainstream schools? If that sounds like a wild idea to you, get a life. It seems like an incredibly straightforward option, and I have no idea why people aren't taking it. Maybe the same mindset as holding onto the Pound Sterling, though with little historical interest nor economic problems. The A Level system is a broken cobbled-together mishmash of diktat after diktat, respected by few and struggled against by hundreds of thousands of students every year. It is a mess, and unfixable without major alterations - alterations policy-makers are not willing, or not able, to effect. So it's broke, and we can't fix it. The IB, on the other hand, is continuing to have great success and is well-respected across the globe, and schools in Britain are increasingly adopting it as an alternative - or sole - curriculum. It's really good. It's not perfect, but it works. It challenges the most talented students, a fact indicated by the offers Oxford and Cambridge give IB students every year: marked out ouf 45, the standard offer from these two universities is between 38 and 42 points, with the Higher Level subjects requiring between 7,6,6 and 7,7,7. Compare this to A Level offers, which are almost always AAA or more.

The IB covers a broader range of subjects in greater depth. It doesn't sacrifice breadth for hoped-for 'depth' (cf: imminent changes in A Level system) - they study more. It's challenging for the most able students; respected and recognised world-wide; the government wouldn't be able to embarrassedly fix results because our examinations scripts would be sent all over the place for marking. It would require teachers to completely revamp their syllabuses and methods, but if the sweeping changes claimed by this 'new' system are really that sweeping then teachers are going to have a hellish settling-down period anyway, so why not go the whole hog with a system that has been tried and tested? They'd have far more fun teaching it. From what I've seen of IB students, they are quite simply better educated - that to me screams volumes, and it's not just because they all seem to have gone to private schools of one kind or another.

IB, please, Education Balls.

(I did A Levels, by the way).

Wednesday, 1 August 2007

Codswallop (i)

All this fuss about TV deceiving its viewers - most recently the ITV Alzheimer's documentary, and before that Blue Peter; A Year With the Queen; Gordon Ramsay's fish non-catching incident, and Bear Grylls' hotel adventures. There have been others.

But I really don't see what all the fuss is about. Well, I do, but I don't understand why it's happening now. We've been fed utter rubbish by the multifarious media for...for all time, really. From the 'best' news-givers to trashy tevelision we're fed lies, half-truths, one-sides and meaningless noises, so why start kicking up about it now? And why not about more important things like the utter bollocks that certain politicians get away with spouting? Maybe it's a good and pointed thing, we're beginning to comment on things like integrity, honesty and fairness...but whether this is extended to include the stuff that really matters remains to be seen - it is, however, a start; better than nowt.

Thursday, 19 July 2007

Conkers

Ed Balls is continuing to impress me. And I haven't yet learnt not to be sarcastic.
Actually, in fairness to the poor bloke, it's probably just that he's now officially a Useless Politician dealing with something with which he has little experience, forced to answer fantastically inane questions posed by ever more ludicrous media representatives. So despite all the inevitable words against "him" that I'll write (and say), I do feel sorry for the chap and am aware it's not all his fault, and that there is lots of good work going on, unreported, somewhere. But he has such a good name to ridicule...so unto the breach.

Balls has recently demonstrated his suitability for his post (as Minister for Children, Skools & Families) by stating that childhood should be a "time for learning and exploring" - profound and groundbreaking stuff. Remember that this man is mainly qualified for his post because he is "father of three" (this fact crops up every time his credentials are needed. Ruth Kelly has more kids - I think that means she was a better Minister, or something). He goes further and demonstrates a naivety that would be laughable if it weren't tragic: "My assumption," he says, "is that if it snows, kids go out and build snowmen and have snowball fights, that in October kids go out and play with conkers, that they play with marbles". Okay, he's probably right with the snow; conkers would be on the agenda if schools allowed kids to play with them (many don't) - but marbles?! When was the last time a (normal) child played with marbles? Balls is supposed to be one of the 'young and in-touch' members of government, not one who reminisces about childhood games of marbles.

Although Balls says some silly things, the context from which the above is taken is less cause for despair. Essentially he is calling for an end to pampered, pandered and stifled children, and a return to fun, less structured, rough-and-tumble childhood (of a kind that involves neither knives nor drugs). One of the results of our compensation culture is the banning of things like conkers, snowball fights and violent tag (well, just tag, but we all know it turns violent. The only time I've been punched properly in the face was in a primary school game - and the assailant wasn't even a Horrid Smelly Boy. There was gushing blood. What larks!). This has led to the most boring playgrounds ever, and Balls is now joining groups such as the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents (a comic misnomer) in calling for a return of common sense and fun. Between them there's an effort to get children outside, running about and - probably, hopefully - breaking a few bones doing exciting things like climbing trees; which is something I very much believe is good. Clearly my (hypothetical) children are going to have a great time - "There you go, kids, there's a field. Go and kick each other around for a bit. Don't be late for tea!"

What made me think about this 'issue', though, aside from the contrasting common sense and utter lunacy involved on either side of the argument (insofar as there is one), is the fact the government doesn't seem to be talking to itself. As ever. In May (*before Balls was in his post*, I hasten to add) there were reports of the newest shiny government Academy in Peterborough (still under construction, I think), which is being built without a playground. It's difficult to get a genuine idea of what's really going on, as all media coverage of it was incredibly one-sided (anti-academy, obviously), and I really suspect that, even more so than usual, we were not getting the full story. That makes the situation impossible to properly evaluate. The government thinking that a school without a playground was a good idea, however, is a cause for concern. Point of info: they are intending no substantial break-times, and a 30-minute lunch break; school hours would be 8.45am till after 4pm (for older pupils). The arguments put forward for why this model is preferable seem to run thus:

1) 2,200 pupils (11-18) would be uncontrollable running around at break times & lunch.
2) Only "organised physical activity" is worthwhile, so any running & playing will take place in designated Physical Education lessons.
3) "Research has shown that if children concentrate on lessons throughout the day, then their work improves." (So no substantial breaks)
4) "Pupils won't need to let off steam because they will not be bored."
5) "We have taken away an uncontrollable space to prevent bullying and truancy."
6) The intention is to treat pupils as responsible 'employees' - and there's no playtime for bankers or lawyers...

These arguments are untenable and completely dismissible. Why?

1) 2,200 pupils might be a lot, but it's not substantially huger than other big schools that manage quite well. Presumably with the necessary increase of staff (and with the vast sums of money these academies apparently have at their disposal), there will be enough people around to control the rampaging teenagers. Anyone who has stepped into a school recently (one that's not been primed for The Inspectors or Important Visitors, that is!) will know that the vast majority of 11-18 yr olds don't run around. A few do. But most mill about, sit in favourite corners, retreat to their classrooms and eat sandwiches, do homework that should have been handed in yesterday, go to detention, stand outside the gates having a fag, go to orchestral rehearsals or clubs...
"So they don't need playgrounds after all!", you might cry - well, yes, they do. For those times when the teenagers stop putting on a strop show and just want to be daft - there's a lot of that in skools (when staff aren't looking). So, there will not be an uncontrollable rabble rioting around the grounds.

2) Everyone knows that designated P.E. lessons only exist to be skived, for half the pupils. For very few they might provide access to sport they wouldn't otherwise do - this is a minority. For the rest, the sporty ones, P.E. is wholly inadequate and a waste of time; because of curriculum pressures (yep, there's a P.E. curriculum) most of the lessons are spent listening to teachers explain the rules, or practicing underarm throwing or balancing techniques or something useless. Very little running around is done. Those who are that way inclined have to find other time and places to do sport - it doesn't always happen in P.E. lessons. To argue that only the "organised" activities are worthwhile, then, is to raise the question "For whom?". (And, again, anyone who's been near a playground will know that there are plenty of kids organising games at lunchtime, involving tearing round the place and jumping on friends. It works).

3) "Research has shown that if children concentrate on lessons throughout the day, then their work improves." Horrendously, this was said by Dr Alan McMurdo, the principal of the academy. Firstly, well, yes - obviously concentration improves work; we don't need a Doctorate to figure that out. But concentration isn't at its best in a full, unbroken day's work! This is madness. Dr McMurdo doesn't come across as the most brilliant potential principal, as demonstrated (again) by this:

4) "Pupils won't need to let off steam because they will not be bored." This indicates a befuddling lack of awareness of what teenagers are like on the part of McMurdo, and the comment is so insanely off the mark that I can't imagine many people not questioning it. How is a school (it's still a school, no matter what fancy name it has) intending to keep 2,200 pupils from boredom? That's not going to happen, ever. Of course some teachers are fantastic and some lessons riveting - but most aren't, and there aren't many people who can get through a school day without day dreaming at some point. Be realistic, you stupid man! What on earth makes him think that his school and his staff (and his pupils) will be so much better than those in the rest of the country? Barking.

5) "We have taken away an uncontrollable space to prevent bullying and truancy." (Miles Delap, managing the project). Outwardly true. Bullying, however, is not going to stop because the playground has gone - it will simply move; and there are more effective ways of tackling it than just removing the spaces. There will always be a toilet/behind-the-bikesheds equivalent, and although environment plays a part, attitude is more the problem. Toilets and playgrounds do not cause bullying. Truancy, hmm - I'm sure there are other places to play truant than in the playground. I used the library. Most normal kids use somewhere out of the school grounds.

6) School pupils are not employees, and they are not adults. They are not in a business workplace - they are at school. There are differences. Treating (particularly young) kids indiscriminately as adults does not make them adults. And it completely goes against what Balls is now campaigning for: the return of childhood.

Sometimes it feels like the world has gone potty.

To end, from the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents stating more profundities, this: "Of course, we don't want exposure to risks where children are likely to die or be permanently injured". I feel safe in the hands of these people.

*******
*Balls quotations and conkers stuff from a Guardian article, 18/07/07
**Academy information was reported in May (link to a Telegraph article, from which quotations were taken). I've not seen anything updating this, though I'll have a search around to see if anyone is making any sense yet.
***Linking to articles on the internet has been an interesting learning curve - though I read all the major broadsheets (and occasionally tabloids) in steady rotation (I don't trust any of them), the Telegraph seems the best to link to. It's got the most searchable database, and more often than not has better pictures. Shame about the political bias, but never mind.

Wednesday, 11 July 2007

Balls

Another rant. And one based on a Telegraph article, no less (apologies).

"We want schools to be world class in 10 years, says Balls", claims the headline (well, the paper has that headline. The internet version is pointlessly different). Why am I annoyed about this? On the surface it seems a perfectly reasonable thing to say. But really, it's a load of balls. And yes, the word "balls" is going to appear a lot - it's a useful name for a politician to have. Sorry, Ed.

Once again there's the promise of "sweeping reforms" and a "review" (another review. If they stopped reviewing and started actually doing something - or, actually, stopped doing things - it might be better). Remarkably, "parents, teachers, universities and pupils will be consulted". That's novel, that is, talking to the people who policies affect; I'm sure that's not been thought of before. There's going to be an "inquiry", too, "into the way children are taught maths amid concern that too many youngsters leave school unable to add up properly" - fine, but ten years ago New Labour initiated a "numeracy strategy" to combat exactly the same problem. A numeracy strategy that Ed Balls has already called "successful". Of course, mistakes aren't admissible in Politix, so all that'll happen is that a very slightly revised version of the "strategy" will appear under a different label (probably "Shopping Skills" or "Life Accountancy").

I get a bit anxious whenever "sweeping reforms" are mentioned. They are invariably not sweeping, and often just make a mess of both the old system and the intended new. It's a load of gobshite. What's worse is that sweeping movements are rarely made by people who are (a) knowledgeable about or (b) genuinely interested in the systems they claim to sweep. They might have a little of both knowledge and interest, but only as much as their job's worth. Shoot me for saying it if you like, but at least Estelle Morris was a teacher - none of her successors have been (Clarke, Kelly, Johnson, Balls), and it shows that they've never been involved in the education of anyone other than themselves. I'm not saying that people necessarily have to have been on the front line to make a good job of being Education Secretary (now Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families), but being actually or at least intellectually involved helps. Curiously, it's John Denham who is S-o-S for Innovation, Universities and Skills - I seriously hope he and Balls occasionally communicate. Please. Even if it's only in passing in the corridor.

Clearly people leaving skool without a decent grasp of the Three Rs is something that still needs to be addressed, though until we develop Matrix-style knowledge implanting it's unlikely we're ever going to get 100% success with this, and why they hell should we? I'm almost cheering on the kids who manage to ignore 12 years of eddicayshun - it's quite impressive, in its own way. Though I'm biased - I did my fair share of ignoring and truanting, but just got away with it because I wasn't too much of a pain in the arse (most of the time). Obviously people are missing out on something by not being able to read, but there are more important things. "Sweeping reforms" aren't what's needed to sort out these fundamental problems, though - gentle changes and thoughtful tinkerings will do enough for that. Sweeping reforms will only be needed or enacted when (not if) the running of the education system is put back in the hands of educators and people who have a real understanding of and long-term interest in what's going on. Fact is, as we stand at the moment, teachers - the people who do stuff - are the people who have the smallest influence on education policy. On what planet does that make sense? The more levels of almost laughably irrelevant bureaucracy above them, the less of a difference in their own classrooms these (mostly) fantastic people can make. Admittedly in a few scary cases that's a good thing (naming no names), but they're the minority.

This has got long, no less ranty and largely disjointed, so it'll be ending soon. But coming back to the original point: why do I find the headline annoying? Because it's meaningless. Andrew Gimson says it well enough - "This is a world in which the declaration of good intentions has become an end in itself". And it's true: so long as inquiries are promised, sweeping reforms threatened and reviews continually undertaken, that's policy sorted. Or not. We don't need "world class" schools - we just need schools that are allowed to do their thing according to their demographies, strengths, and values. I'm not saying that these shouldn't be monitored at all (of course they should), but they shouldn't be overpowered by the clueless, gesturing and empty words of Politix. "World class" sounds impressive, but isn't a helpful aim. What's needed (and realistic) are "community class" or "education class". No matter how well-intentioned, people who get dragged into Politix seem to end up spouting a load of balls. I'll be staying out of it, thanks, and just working on my square metre of influence.

Thursday, 5 July 2007

Miseducation (i)

There will be more on this, no doubt. But briefly,

I've been reading Aristotle's Poetics and the experience has been most frustrating; not the text so much (I've not finished it yet), but the process of reading it. What's bugging me is the fact that Aristotle's 'views' about Tragedy are talked about all over the place (well, not normally in the canned veg isle of the supermarket*, but you know what I mean), incorrectly. I don't mean incorrectly in the sense of 'there are lots of interpretations and this is the one I choose'; incorrectly like 'I don't know there are any interpretations. This is what it means.'

Probably annoyed about this because I thought I vaguely understood the basic concepts behind Aristotelian tragedy, but quite evidently that's not true. What seems to have happened is that I was taught about "Aristotle" at skool by people who almost certainly hadn't read Poetics, and they were probably taught by people who hadn't read it either, and so on. So there was me thinking I had a clue, but I don't: what I 'know' is at best an offensively over-simplified and at worst totally WRONG version of a Chinese Whisper that may once have been about Aristotle. Which is very annoying. So far, every 'standard' piece of tragic terminology (mimesis, hamartia, katharsis, pathos, praxis, etc.) I've come across in this text (and its comprehensive introduction by Malcom Heath) has meant either something different to that I was taught, or something so ambiguous or fluid or contextually-dependent that my 'definition' of it is absurdly out of whack. Bummer. My own fault - should have read the text itself long ago.

But it is very annoying that, at skool, kids are taught a weird mixture of lies and semi-truths, and almost always second-hand. Either give them the original texts (or scientific experiments, or whatever medium we're dealing with) and help them draw their own conclusions about stuff (if they're way-out, well, that's what Teacher's for); or only 'teach' them things they're actually capable of understanding (and it's not for some ludicrously out-of-touch government department run by an economist of all people to state what exactly it is kids of different ages might or might not be capable of understanding). It's irritating that 16-yr olds are told that electrons do one thing, and then when they start their AS Levels at 17 they are told almost the opposite; by the time they get to A Level, electrons probably don't exist, or something. Okay, so sometimes stuff has to be simplified - but at least tell them that what they're being taught is more an analogy than fact. And when it comes to literature/texts, doesn't it make more sense to avoid imposing complicated theoretical theories (i.e. Aristotle's, in this case) if it's deemed that the theories proper are way above the students' abilities? Why pay lip service to it at all?

Pah. Excuse the grousing, but I've got to go and figure out Aristotle. Again. Properly, this time.

********************

*ISLE?! What kind of word is isle?! It should be pronounced 'eyes-ull' or 'eyes-lee'. The more I look at it the weirder it is, and I'm not sure any more if it's the right word at all. Isle. The OED doesn't mention anything about supermarkets.**

**Yes, um...aisle. THAT would explain why it looked wrong! Duh.

Sunday, 1 July 2007

Hysterias (ii)

University applications. It's that time of year when Sixth Formers start thinking about them. Well, actually, there are several times in the year when they do - but post-exams (now) is one of them. (The others are in Sept/Oct, UCAS deadlines; Nov/Dec, interviews; Dec/Jan, post-interviews...brief respite until May/June, thence exams; August, A Level results. This leaves four months when they're not thinking about them). Lots of earnest questions being asked, and they land in my inbox by the dozen - questions about Cambridge, about the English Tripos, about Newnham College. I like answering them, and it's only very occasionally that a vitriolic response wants to escape into the tippytappy keyboard from my fingertips (normally in response to "Is Newnham full of lesbians?") - and the causticity has been suppressed thus far. But there is something a bit wonky about the whole thing...

For starters, there is an utter lack of common sense in about 70% of questions asked - or it might in many cases be called laziness. The University and College prospectuses give much (though not all) the information needed. Dear applicants, please read them! The various prospectuses sit as a pile on my desk and most often the direct answer to the question asked is contained within their slightly fishy-smelling pages. Though I have the advantage of knowing the system (and, by now, the page numbers for every answer possibly required, groan), it really isn't that hard to find what's needed - and a wee bit of initiative wouldn't be amiss in a Cambridge (or indeed university) applicant. Please?

The delicious main course of the affair is a more serious one. Misinformation and the dogged persistence of Oxbridge Myths (these latter are seriously tough cookies, some of them have been told for over 100 years!). The Access & Admissions people (various academics, staff and students) work very hard to distribute up-to-date and genuinely helpful information, but it seems not to permeate into the application atmosphere. It's not just the completely mad stuff - like the idea that setting fire to your interviewer's hair will make their boring day more interesting and thereby gain you a place at the University - it's a bit more sinister than that. The idea that if you attend your local comprehensive (or have a northern accent) you will instantly arouse dislike. The idea that if you go to a public school (or have a Home Counties accent) you will instantly arouse dislike. Or sport - competence at sports attracts suspicion (brawn and brains incompatible); incompetence at sport means instant rejection ("What? Not captain of the county lacrosse team? You miserable specimen!"). Naturally, the interviewers are out to get everyone. You have to be a certified genius to stand a chance. And once you're safely at the University you are chained to your desk for 10 hrs a day...or is it that everyone spends all their time in the bar, the work getting done magically by the telekinesis of genius? I can't remember - it's all got so complicated.
Anyway, there's still a huge volume of work to be done in this area - both in getting rid of any wobbly bits at the University end (the ethnic minorities and state vs. private school chestnuts are still hanging about), and in simply getting applicants to CALM DOWN. Just read a good book to take your mind off it all. Please?

A short but sweet dessert. The number of [potential] applicants who seem almost entirely disinterested in their subject (or any other subject) is scary. It's something that carries through to the University population proper too, to an extent. Yes, yes, I know it's not cool to say that Physics is Phun or that Readin' is Rockin', but a little enthusiasm would be nice. Please?

There's a lot of fun to be had answering the more sensible questions, though. Many of the more astute queries raise serious questions about the nature of education generally, and the UK university system entire. And there are gaps in the official information that need filling (there are probably things that can't 'officially' be said - like the fact that English is The Best Subject. It's absolutely true, but there's probably some rule that means it can't go on the front of all the prospectuses). It's just that after sifting through a silly number of emails today all asking some variation of, "If I don't own a business, captain a national sports team, sit on a board of trustees and play seven instruments, will I automatically be rejected?", it's time for a cuppa. The answer to that question (and the vast majority of its variants), by the way, is 'no'. As is the answer to the lesbian question.

Saturday, 30 June 2007

Hysterias (i)

What I want to write about is the recent car bombs in London and Glasgow, but I lack the articulacy demanded; and I lack a point, really. Other than the fact that it makes no sense whatsoever. The result of targetting explicitly public places is simply public fear - not governmental policy changes (except to everyone's detriment), not religious or cultural understanding, certainly not human communication. Maybe I lack a point because it lacks one. There's no human gain from the acts, except of course for the leaders of whichever country, organisation or community is committing the violence at the time; but even that gain is tenuous (and heavily reliant on the manipulation by/of the media in every region), and liable to volatile changes. Britain and America are not gaining politically, economically or culturally from their warfare in the Middle East (and elsewhere for that matter). There is no gain for religion. Though too much is made of the Islamic connection, it is one of the forces in play (or at least the violence actively hides under the guise of Islam; and in turn Islam is demonised by much of the West[ern media] and real issues hidden, conveniently for our governments, under its name and outwardly Other conventions). The Qur'an isn't about war or hatred - save a few clauses about defence and proportionate justice (no different to Old or New Testaments, in this sense) - and it certainly isn't about indiscriminate homicide. Devotion to God, 'islam', is not being enhanced in all of this.

Who is getting anything out of this? Who?
Selfish buggers, people are - though I'd argue no more so than any other animal fighting for survival, it's just that our terms of survival aren't quite the same - but capable of some Quite Good things. Why the Quite Good majority aren't now rising up and saying STOP, I have no idea: fear, wilful myopia, ignorance, selfishness, they'll all play a part. But we are capable of overriding all of those, in certain circumstances - now would be quite a good time. Eurgh it makes me so cross...and inarticulate.

**********************

So, now that I've not written about the car bombings (ahem), onwards.